Date: 10.1.2017 / Article Rating: 4 / Votes: 630
Uii.essayroad.cloudns.cx #Ceo asda

Recent Posts

Home >> Uncategorized >> Ceo asda

Ceo asda

Nov/Mon/2017 | Uncategorized








Asda boss steps down as supermarket starts to halt sales slide

Ceo asda

Pay For Essay Writing Service -
Asda appoints new CEO as it claims brand is finally realising its

Nov 06, 2017 Ceo asda, buy essay online -
UK supermarket Asda names Roger Burnley as CEO from Jan 2018

anti-sasunaru essay Description: Just read it. I think my post is on the 4th or 5th page. The thing is I really dislike teammate pairings, why? Because of the seesaw effect, what is the seesaw effect? Let me explain it to you in a story. Team #99 is consisted of Boy #1, Boy #2 and Girl. They were walking in a playground when Boy #2 spotted a seesaw and ceo asda, wanted to get on it so Boy1 and Boy2 get on two ends of the seesaw. The boys ask Girl to come over too because she#39;s part of the Characters team.

Because Girl is ceo asda friends with both of the team, she decides to sit in the middle: Now, Team #99 is differ from islam? all happy playing on their perfectly balanced seesaw when suddenly Girl decides she has a crush on Boy1. After all, he#39;s cool, he#39;s handsome, way more attractive than Boy2 who can get really annoying. She#39;s going to want to get closer to Boy1 on the seesaw. Now substitute Team #99 with either Team7, Team Gai or Team Kurenai and you will catch my drift and what I#39;m saying. You see, Shikamaru particularly stands out of his group and as one of the original genin. Ceo Asda! He#39;s a genius, he was the only one to Female Characters in Hamlet Essay become a Chuunin in ceo asda the fake exams and he went to attack the Akatsuki without the judaism from aid of Chouji and Ino. Ceo Asda! In conclusion, the current situation of Team Asuma looks like this: Okay, look what happens if ShikaIno became canon: In turn, if InoCho happened, there would be some balance added to the team.

You see, Sakura#39;s immaturity was especially shown on american her relationship with Sasuke and Naruto. How the heck is she supposed to ceo asda mature from that stage of insulting Naruto and why is euthanasia illegal, favoring Sasuke if she#39;s going to end up with Sasuke? She can#39;t, it just doesn#39;t make sense. SasuSaku fan Wrote: Can#39;t she mature while liking Sasuke at the same time? Not in the literary sense of things, and not according to my seesaw theory. Its not good symbolism. Sakura#39;s character development really does revolve around getting over Sasuke. Sakura ending up with Sasuke would show that she entirely revolves around him - exactly like the beginning of Part1 - and that would be leaving her with a 2Dimensional personality and character development.

Excuse me, the main girl totally revolving on getting a boyfriend? Sexism ahoy. How do you know that Sakura has no feelings for Sasuke anymore? Several things. For one, she accepted going out on a date with Naruto. Ceo Asda! Last time I checked, friends hung out, not dated. If she still liked Sasuke in a romantic way, she would have not accepted going out on american vs japan a date with anyone, I know I wouldn#39;t go out on a date with a guy if I was in love with someone else as it would just be leading them on. That#39;s not all, there#39;s also the scene where Sakura cut her hair. Remember why she grew it out? For Sasuke. And what?

She cut it. In a way, she is cutting away her feelings for Sasuke. Ceo Asda! Sasuke kept Sakura immature. SasuSaku fan Wrote: Stronger possibly, but not mature. Why Is Illegal! Let#39;s look at ceo asda the bit after Naruto#39;s battle with Gaara. Monitoring Processes All Of Project! Proof?

Sakura#39;s character development did not start until after Sasuke left. Kishimoto said that Sakura#39;s feelings for ceo asda Sasuke were genuine unlike Ino#39;s#33; For one, never trust translators, especially when it comes to such a general word like #39;love#39;. Why? Because its easy to argue that Sakura#39;s genuine feelings for humanistic theory psychology Sasuke was just caring for a teammate and ceo asda, having a crush at the same time. This gives gives off the illusion that Sakura actually loves Sasuke, but its what it is, an illusion. Genuine love as a friend and vicks company, teammate, yes, genuine romantic love, no. What about that scene in the forest when Sakura calmed Sasuke#39;s rage? (Its also where we get the idea that she#39;s going to ceo asda be his savior) Its been hinted at over and over again that Sasuke#39;s savior will be Naruto, and mainly Naruto and I will argue why later. The thing is, Naruto was unconscious, Lee was unconscious.

No one else could have done it, in processes the other project fact, they ALL had to be unconscious for Sakura to have that important hair-cutting scene I mentioned before. Either way, Sasuke was needed because at the time Sakura had stronger feelings for him than Naruto and ceo asda, Lee and monitoring and controlling the other project management groups., therefore provoked a stronger reaction. Besides, the scene happened before Sasuke chose to go with Orochimaru, and I#39;ll get back to that later. But Sakura told Sasuke that she loved him#33; Plus that she would give up everything to be with him#33; I think that proves only even more that that crush is immature because ALL of us are willing to do the same for our first love/crush, I know I did. How many do we actually end up with him? Very, very few, why? Because we mature. Ceo Asda! In fact, if Sakura was mature by then, she wouldn#39;t have fallen for theory Sasuke to begin with. Ceo Asda! If you read A Hero of Female Characters Our Time by Lermontov you#39;ll understand what I#39;m talking about. Ceo Asda! And no, I#39;m not comparing two works of two different artists, I#39;m using it as an example, just like I learn in my IB Junior year English class. (Mah skool is theory bedar dan urs lolol#33;1) (The above) was a SasuSaku moment#33; Sasuke left.

End of story. What about ceo asda Sakura#39;s reaction to Sai#39;s insult and Sai being so shocked about it? Naruto#39;s reaction was exactly the same. However, the vicks company reason why Sai was shocked from Sakura#39;s reaction was because she used the same #39;smile to ceo asda conceal intentions#39; tactic he uses, and that surprised him. The reason that scene was important was to and controlling processes overlap all of the other groups. show how bad Naruto felt on how he couldn#39;t stop Sasuke from betraying the village and because of that couldn#39;t defend him against Sai#39;s insults. Ceo Asda! And how about when Sakura saw Sasuke again?

She was very shocked. Euthanasia! The last time she had seen Sasuke was when she declared her supposed feelings for ceo asda him, and in what way does judaism from islam?, now she saw Sasuke attempting to kill Naruto behind Orochimaru, hey, that#39;s stressful you know. Anybody would have been shocked if only out of fear. Besides, even if you look for deeper meaning, it could only too easily mean that she gave up on him at ceo asda that moment. We really don#39;t know, so no jumping to conclusions. Sakura spent all her time obsessing over Sasuke to only give it up later/End up with someone else? Yes actually, its called maturing and character development. And Controlling Processes Overlap The Other Process Groups.! Hell, NARUTO is all about friendship between the ceo asda three teammates. Kishimoto isn#39;t going to throw that away in exchange for romance.

This isn#39;t a shojo manga. The three saying their goals at the beginning could be seen as foreshadowing. Sasuke killing his brother and reviving his clan, Naruto becoming Hokage, and Sakura getting Sasuke. Lets look at that bit again, shall we? Close, but no cigar. Sasuke and Naruto mentioned their goals, but Sakura only said her favorite thing was Sasuke and that she hated Naruto.

She never mentioned it was her goal to theory be with Sasuke. Besides, I think it was mentioned later that Sakura#39;s goal was to become a strong kunoichi, not end up with Sasuke. Its possible that Sasuke did have feelings for Sakura. Ceo Asda! No, its not. Why? Well, because the why is so called love triangle that was shown to us when Sakura and Sasuke were introduced.

Naruto having strong feelings for ceo asda Sakura would be one side. Euthanasia! Sakura having strong feelings for Sasuke would be the ceo asda other, and euthanasia, Sasuke having strong feelings for Naruto is the last. Sasuke: Don#39;t you envy him being alone, not having parents nag at ceo asda you all the time. You make me sick#33; Sasuke: You#39;re just as bad as Naruto. Why waste your time flirting when you should be practicing? Even his skills are better than yours#33; Neji to illegal Naruto (not exact quote): You have better eyes than mine. Only you can save Sasuke from darkness now. Warning: Yes, you guessed it, it is very pro-NaruHina. Ceo Asda! NaruSaku fan Wrote: NaruHina has no chance of happening instead of NaruSaku#33; I would agree.

But remember my statement about theory how crushes wore off in Part 2? Lee#39;s crush wore off, Ino#39;s crush wore off, Sakura#39;s crush wore off, Hinata#39;s crush did not wear off. Ceo Asda! If Kishimoto would want to put NaruSaku instead, he would have taken Hinata#39;s crush away instead of complicating things. He didn#39;t. Maybe he has planned doing something with them? Its sure been hinted at. NaruSaku fan: Naruto still loves/likes Sakura#33; No, he doesn#39;t. I won#39;t argue on Sakura loving Naruto, but if that#39;s the case, then its not requited. American! Naruto knew and accepted that Sakura did not like him back in Part1 right before the the Sasuke Retrieval ARK: Naruto: Sakura-chan, you really like Sasuke huh? -smile- NaruSaku fan: What are you saying? Naruto never gives up, its his nindo#33; Sometimes part of ceo asda learning is accepting that you lost and humanistic, moving on. Even so, Naruto has never told Sakura he loved her, and ceo asda, it was never his goal to get together with Sakura. Naruto#39;s goals are to be acknowledged, to american vs japan become Hokage and to bring Sasuke back.

Besides, why would he need to work to ceo asda be acknowledged by Sakura when he is already acknowledged by Hinata? Let#39;s look at Hinata#39;s theme: Believe in yourself. How would that theme fit if Naruto ends up never acknowledging Hinata and rejects her for Sakura, someone who rejected him throughout most of Part1? That#39;s not fair. Oh, and not to forget, Naruto#39;s nindo is never take back my words, not giving up. He has never mentioned he would get Sakura to love him in Part1, so I don#39;t see what the Female problem is. Naruto loves Sakura#33; Again, I#39;ll refer to the manga; And by the way, Hinata#39;s theme is exactly the same. NaruSaku fan: NaruSaku is canon#33; Have they told eachother they love eachother? No.

Have they kissed? No. I know it is ceo asda a shonen manga but there are always something that will indicate a pairing is canon. Look at Asuma/Kurenai, when Asuma died Kurenai had the bad omen, they constantly dated as you can see when Team Asuma had flashbacks. Asuma/Kurenai was canon. NaruSaku is not, if it were I wouldn#39;t be argueing this. The hero always gets the girl/Sakura is first prize while Hinata is runner-up, Naruto can#39;t get her#33; Prizes? Sexism alert#33; Look people, it wouldn#39;t be the first time the main character would get paired up with a side-character and it certainly wouldn#39;t be the last. Women aren#39;t prizes to be won. What about Yamato#39;s statement?

Sakura in reality, you. -297. Oh, and talking about Ch297, guess who was on the cover of monitoring processes overlap all of project that chapter? You guessed it, Hinata Hyuuga. Ceo Asda! No, it wasn#39;t a coincidence and why is illegal, I#39;ll go more into it later. Ceo Asda! (This is probably Kishimoto#39;s way of saying You guessed wrong#33; ) Naruto would get Sakura to acknowledge him by loving him#33; Not necessarily. Sakura already acknowledges Naruto, she already knows about Kyuubi, she knows him probably better than most people. If the above is the case, then why hasn#39;t NaruSaku happened yet? They already know eachother well, you#39;d think they#39;d be totally over on eachother by now but they#39;re not. Makes you think, doesn#39;t it?

What about the processes overlap the other management groups. date? I#39;m no hypocrite. I think Kishimoto put the date as his own way of ceo asda showing us that Sakura forgot her feelings for Sasuke without having to euthanasia illegal put actual important romance in ceo asda it and adding to us that ShikaTema hint. Hell, Naruto hadn#39;t even said the word #39;date#39; yet so I don#39;t think it counts in this category. Naruto only teases Sakura, trying to cheer themselves up and doing it for overlap process groups. #39;old time#39;s sake#39; and Naruto hasn#39;t mentioned any romantic intentions to Sakura since then.

As I mentioned before, Naruto no longer has a crush on Sakura. Oh, and by the way, according to ceo asda what#39;s translated, Kishimoto mentioned that the date was not romance. Vicks Company! No, I am not a hypocrite, love is a general word, romance is not. The NaruHina in ceo asda the anime were only fillers#33; True. But why did the vs japan animators necessarily put NaruHina in the fillers? Why#39;d they do that if they knew it could end some other way ending up with loads of dissapointed fans on ceo asda their asses?

It would be ridiculous and unprofessional. Its absolutely normal for manga authors to and controlling processes overlap the other project process tell animators how they#39;re going to end the manga or at ceo asda least what they have planned. I don#39;t think the animators are stupid enough to american vs japan put NaruHina in if they knew NaruSaku would or could happen. Ceo Asda! NaruSaku fan Wrote: Hinata#39;s family wouldn#39;t let her#33;/Incest is practiced in the Hyuuga clan#33; One; It has NEVER been mentioned that the way does judaism from Hyuuga#39;s intermarry and I believe that#39;s just NejiHina fanon speculation. Two; Its been foreshadowed that the ceo asda Hyuugas will have a family reform and american vs japan, three; I don#39;t think they#39;d mind an exception to that rule with the future Hokage. Angst just makes it all better.

Hinata can be strong without Naruto#33; Wouldn#39;t that show her character development like you said with the ceo asda crushes? If anyone were to in what way does from ask me this, I#39;d applaud them for being a good debater, but it won#39;t work on ceo asda me. American Vs Japan! Hinata#39;s source for inspiration? Naruto, Hinata#39;s reason to grow? Naruto. Unlike Sakura#39;s crush for Sasuke keeping her immature, Hinata#39;s crush for ceo asda Naruto did the opposite, made her mature, made her stronger, how would that fit if Hinata ends up giving up? Yes, Hinata can become acknowledged by her clan and way does differ from islam?, become strong, but it wouldn#39;t resolve her feelings for Naruto. I already proved how Sakura#39;s feelings for Sasuke had resolved, how Naruto#39;s feelings for Sakura had resolved, but Hinata#39;s - maybe being a minor character - feelings have yet to be resolved.

Hell, its even be foreshadowed that Hinata will eventually confess her feelings for Naruto, let#39;s look at the second databook: Hinata, always feeling the same towards Naruto. Will the day come when she can face him directly? Oh, and let#39;s look at this picture Kishimoto himself drew, this is not fanart. This being the ceo asda rough draft of the judaism cover of the ceo asda so on the familiar chapter of american vs japan 297: This golden light is only too obviously Naruto. Ceo Asda! Oh, and just to stick it in why is illegal here, Hinata was the one that saw Naruto leave Konoha, not Sakura. Ceo Asda! - There#39;s no reason for Naruto and Sakura to be lovers as they#39;re perfectly fine as friends. Sakura already has a good portion of the spotlight, especially in a shonen manga. However, everytime Hinata gets the spotlight it has something to american do with Naruto. NaruHina not happening would be severely neglecting Hinata, as a minor character, and her theme. - The Seesaw effect. - If Kishimoto wanted NaruSaku he would have made Hinata#39;s feelings fade, but he didn#39;t. - If Kishimoto wanted NaruSaku, he would have probably made it canon by now, they#39;re all alone without Sasuke, so why hasn#39;t it happened? -The NARUTO manga is all about ceo asda friendship.

Kishimoto is not going to theory psychology throw that away to pave way for a romantic relationship between Team7 and/or Sai. He#39;s going to ceo asda want to either leave them single or pair them up outside of the team. More reference to why is the seesaw effect. - Naruto already gave up on ceo asda Sakura at the end of Part1. It would be pointless to monitoring and controlling processes overlap all of the other process bring back his feelings; it wouldn#39;t help the plot, and it certainly wouldn#39;t help his character development. Ceo Asda! -Sakura knows about Hinata#39;s feelings for Naruto, it wouldn#39;t be very nice on her part to still chase after him. -Continuing from the why is euthanasia illegal last point, both Kiba and Shino know very well of Hinata#39;s feelings for Naruto and support her. If NaruHina didn#39;t happen, it would not only bring down Hinata, but also all of Team 8/Kurenai.

Hell, it seems like all of Team 8#39;s purpose revolves around Hinata#39;s feelings for Naruto. I could use how Shino wasn#39;t included in the Sasuke Retrieval ARK as evidence for ceo asda it. EDIT2: This is an arguement supported with facts like anything you write in school. It is not a fact and why is euthanasia illegal, I#39;m not saying that SasuSaku nor NaruSaku will never happen in the future, I#39;m argueing against SasuSaku and NaruSaku being canon now. Ceo Asda! I#39;m not claiming all I say is a fact, its an opinion where I use a theory. Now go take an English class and vs japan, write a few essays on books before coming back. -kicked out ceo asda, of the AMC- You see, Sakura#39;s immaturity was especially shown on her relationship with Sasuke and Naruto. How the heck is she supposed to mature from that stage of insulting Naruto and favoring Sasuke if she#39;s going to end up with Sasuke? She can#39;t, it just doesn#39;t make sense.

I think that she realized that the world DOESN#39;T revolve around her sasuke-kun, but I still think that she loves him. So you#39;re right, she matures by realizing that the world is entirely made of illegal her and Sasuke--- but that doesn#39;t deny the right for her to still love him, and for ceo asda him to have the and controlling all of process potential of loving her back. Ceo Asda! In fact, there are a lot of things Sasuke does that hints that he cares for Sakura-- maybe not as a lover, but at monitoring processes overlap all of management least as a friend. I think that, not only does Sakura#39;s character develop, but her realationship with Sasuke, and even Naruto develops as well, as time passes.

How to buy essay cheap with no worries -
Asda boss steps down as supermarket starts to halt sales slide

Nov 06, 2017 Ceo asda, buying essays online -
Asda promotes lieutenant as CEO steps down after 18 months

Research in Programming Languages. Is there still research to be done in ceo asda Programming Languages? This essay touches both on the topic of humanistic, programming languages and on the nature of ceo asda, research work. I am mostly concerned in analyzing this question in the context of Academia, i.e. within the expectations of academic programs and research funding agencies that support research work in psychology the STEM disciplines ( Science, Technology, Engineering, and ceo asda, Mathematics ). This is not the only possible perspective, but it is the one I am taking here. PLs are dear to vicks company my heart, and ceo asda, a considerable chunk of my career was made in that area. As a designer, there is something fundamentally interesting in designing a language of any kind.

Itís even more interesting and vicks company, gratifying when people actually start exercising those languages to create non-trivial software systems. As a user, I love to use programming languages that I havenít used before, even when the languages in question make me curse every other line. But the truth of the matter is that ever since I finished my Ph.D. in the late 90s, and especially since I joined the ranks of Academia, I have been having a hard time convincing myself that research in PLs is a worthy endeavor. I feel really bad about ceo asda, my rational arguments against it, though. Hence this essay.

Perhaps by the time I am done with it I will have come to terms with this dilemma. Back in vicks company the 50s, 60s and 70s, programming languages were a BigDeal, with large investments, upfront planning, and big drama on standardization committees (Ada was the epitome of that model). Things have changed dramatically during the 80s. Since the 90s, a considerable percentage of new languages that ended up being very popular were designed by lone programmers, some of ceo asda, them kids with no research inclination, some as a side hobby, and without any grand goal other than either making some routine activities easier or for plain hacking fun. Examples: PHP, by Rasmus Lerdorf circa 1994, ďoriginally used for tracking visits to his online resume, he named the suite of scripts ĎPersonal Home Page Tools,í more frequently referenced as ĎPHP Tools.í Ē [1] PHP is american vs japan a marvel of how a horrible language can become the ceo asda foundation of large numbers of Female Characters, applicationsÖ for a second time! Worse is Better redux.

According one informal but interesting survey, PHP is now the 4th most popular programming language out there, losing only to ceo asda C, Java and american vs japan, C++. JavaScript, by Brendan Eich circa 1995, ďPlus, I had to be done in ten days or something worse than JS would have happened.Ē [2] According to that same survey, JavaScript is the 5th most popular language, and ceo asda, I suspect it is climbing up that rank really fast. It may be #1 by now. Python, by Guido van Rossum circa 1990, ďI was looking for a Ďhobbyí programming project that would keep me occupied during the in what from week around Christmas.Ē [3] Python comes at ceo asda, #6, and its strong adoption by scientific computing communities is well know. Ruby, by why is euthanasia illegal, Yukihiro ďMatzĒ Matsumoto circa 1994, ďI wanted a scripting language that was more powerful than Perl, and more object-oriented than Python. Thatís why I decided to design my own language.Ē [4] At #10 in that survey. Compare this mindset with the context in which the the older well-known programming languages emerged: Fortran, 50s, originally developed by IBM as part of their core business in computing machines. Cobol, late 50s, designed by a large committee from the onset, sponsored by the DoD. Ceo Asda! Lisp, late 50s, main project occupying 2 professors at american, MIT and ceo asda, their students, with the grand goal of american vs japan, producing an algebraic list processing language for artificial intelligence work, also funded by the DoD. C, early 70s, part of the large investment that Bell Labs was doing in ceo asda the development of Unix.

Smalltalk, early 70s, part of a large investment that Xerox did in ďinventing the futureĒ of computers. Back then, developing a language processor was, indeed, a very big deal. Computers were slow, didnít have a lot of memory, the language processors had to be written in low-level assembly languagesÖ it wasnít something someone would do in their rooms as a hobby, to put it mildly. Since the 90s, however, with the why is illegal emergence of PCs and of decent low-level languages like C, developing a language processor is no longer a BigDeal. Hence, languages like PHP and JavaScript. There is ceo asda a lot of fun in designing new languages, but this fun is not an exclusive right of researchers with, or working towards, Ph.Ds. Given all the knowledge about programming languages these days, anyone can do it. And many do.

And hereís the first itchy point: there appears to be no correlation between the success of a programming language and vs japan, its emergence in the form of someoneís doctoral or post-doctoral work. This bothers me a lot, as an ceo asda academic. It appears that deep thoughts, consistency, rigor and all other things we value as scientists arenít that important for mass adoption of vicks company, programming languages. But then again, Iím not the ceo asda first to way does say it. Itís just that this phenomenon is hard to digest, and if you really grasp it, it has tremendous consequences. If people (the potential users) donít care about conceptual consistency, why do we keep on ceo asda, trying to achieve that? To be fair, some of those languages designed in the 90s as side projects, as they became important, eventually became more rigorous and consistent, and attracted a fair amount of academic attention and industry investment. For example, the Netscape JavaScript hacks quickly fell on Guy Steeleís lap resulting in humanistic the ECMAScript specification. Python was never a hack even if it started as a Christmas hobby. Ruby is a fun language and ceo asda, quite elegant from the beginning. PHPÖ wellÖ itís fun for possibly the wrong reasons.

But the core of the vicks company matter is ceo asda that ďthe right thingĒ was not the goal. It seems that a reliable implementation of a language that addresses an important practical need is the key for vicks company, the popularity of a programming language. But being opportunistic isnít what research is ceo asda supposed to be aboutÖ (or is vs japan it?) Also to be fair, not all languages designed in ceo asda the 90s and later started as side projects. For example, Java was a relatively large investment by Sun Microsystems. So was .NET later by Microsoft. And, finally, all of these new languages, even when created over a week as someoneís pet project, sit on the shoulders of all things that existed before. This leads me to the second itch: one striking commonality in all modern programming languages, especially the popular ones, is how little innovation there is in them ! Without exception, including the languages developed in humanistic theory psychology research groups, they all feel like mashups of ceo asda, concepts that already existed in programming languages in 1979, wrapped up in their own idiosyncratic syntax. (I lied: exceptions go to theory psychology aspects and monads both of which came in the 90s)

So one pertinent question is: given that not much seems to have emerged since 1979 (thatís 30+ years!), is there still anything to innovate in programming languages? Or have we reached the asymptotic plateau of innovation in this area? I need to make an important detour here on the nature of research. Perhaps Iím completely off; perhaps producing innovative new software is ceo asda not a goal of humanistic theory, [STEM] research . Under this approach, any software work is dismissed from ceo asda STEM pursuits, unless it is necessary for in what way does judaism differ from islam?, some specific goal ó like if you want to study some far-off galaxy and you need an ceo asda IT infrastructure to collect the data and make simulations (S for why is euthanasia, Science); or if you need some glue code for piecing existing systems together (T for Technology); or if you need to improve the performance of ceo asda, something that already exists (E for Engineering); or if you are a working on some Mathematical model of computation and humanistic theory, want to make your ideas come to life in the form of a language (M for Mathematics). This is an ceo asda extreme submissive view of software systems, one that places software in the back sit of STEM and that denies the monitoring overlap all of project management existence of value in research in/by software itself.

If we want to lead something on ceo asda, our own, letís justÖ do empirical studies of vicks company, technology or become biologists/physicists/chemists/mathematicians or make existing things perform better or do theoretical/statistical models of universes that already exist or that are created by others. Right? I confess I have a dysfunctional relationship with this idea. Personally, I canít be happy without creating software things, but I have been able to make my scientist-self function both as a cold-minded analyst and, at times, as an expert passenger in someone elseís research project. The design work, for ceo asda, me, has moved to sabbatical time, evenings and weekends; I donít publish it [much] other than the code itself and some informal descriptions. And yet, I loathe this situation. I loathe it because itís is clear to me that software systems are something very, very special. Vicks Company! Software revolutionized everything in ceo asda unexpected ways, including the methods and practices that our esteemed colleagues in the ďhardĒ sciences hold near and dear for a very long time. The evolution of information technology in the past 60 years has been _way_ off from what our colleagues thought they needed. Over and over again, software systems have been created that werenít part of any scientific project, as such, and that ended up playing a central role in Science. Instead of trying to mimic our colleaguesí traditional practices, ďcomputer scientistsĒ ought to be showing the way to why is euthanasia illegal a new kind of science ó maybe that new kind of science or that one or maybe something else.

I dare to ceo asda suggest that the Female in Hamlet Essay something else is ceo asda related to the design of way does islam?, things that have software in them. It should not be called Science. It is a bit like Engineering, but itís not it either because weíre not dealing [just] with physical things. Technology doesnít cut it either. It needs a new name, something that denotes ďthe design of ceo asda, things with software in them.Ē I will call it Design for short, even though that word is so abused that it has lost its meaning.

Letís assume, then, that itís acceptable to create/design new things ó innovate ó in american the context of doctoral work. Now comes the real hard question. If anyone ó researchers, engineers, talented kids, summer interns ó can design and implement programming languages, what are the actual hard goals that doctoral research work in programming languages seeks that distinguishes it from what anyone can do? Let me attempt to answer these questions, first, with some well-known goals of language design: Performance ó one can always have more of this; certain application domains need it more than others. This usually involves having to come up with interesting data structures and algorithms for ceo asda, the implementation of PLs that werenít easy to devise. Human Productivity ó one can always want more of Characters, this. There is no ending to trying to make development activities easier/faster. Verifiability ó in some domains this is important.

There are other goals, but they are second-order. Ceo Asda! For example, languages may also need to catch up with innovations in hardware design ó multi-core comes to mind. This is a second-order goal, the real goal behind it is to increase performance by taking advantage of potentially higher-performing hardware architectures. In other words, someone wanting to do doctoral research work in programming languages ought to have one or more of way does from islam?, these goals in mind, and ó very important ó ought to be ready to demonstrate how his/her ideas meet those goals . If you tell me that your language makes something run faster, consume less energy, makes some task easier or results in programs with less bugs, the scientist in me demands that you show me the data that supports such claims. A lot of ceo asda, research activity in programming languages falls under the performance goal, the Engineering side of things. I think everyone in our field understands what this entails, and is able to differentiate good work from bad work under that goal. But a considerable amount of research activities in programming languages invoke the human productivity argument; entire sub-fields have emerged focusing on the engineering of languages that are believed to processes project process increase human productivity. So Iím going to focus on ceo asda, the human productivity goal.

The human productivity argument touches on the core of psychology, what attracts most of us to ceo asda creating things: having a direct positive effect on other people. It has been carelessly invoked since the beginning of Computer Science. (I highly recommend this excellent essay by Stefan Hanenberg published at Onward! 2010 with a critique of software scienceís neglect of monitoring and controlling processes all of the other management process groups., human factors) Unfortunately, this argument is the ceo asda hardest to defend. Vs Japan! In fact, I am yet to see the ceo asda first study that convincingly demonstrates that a programming language, or a certain feature of programming languages, makes software development a more productive process. Monitoring Processes The Other Project Process! If you know of ceo asda, such study, please point me to it. I have seen many observational studies and controlled experiments that try to do it [5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, among many]. I think those studies are really important, there ought to be more of humanistic theory psychology, them, but they are always very difficult to ceo asda do [well]. Unfortunately, they always fall short of giving us any definite conclusions because, even when they are done right, correlation does not imply causation. Hence the never-ending ping-pong between studies that focus on the same thing and seem to reach opposite conclusions, best known in vicks company the health sciences. Ceo Asda! We are starting to see that ping-pong in software science too, for example 7 vs 9. But at least these studies show some correlations, or lack thereof, given specific experimental conditions, and they open the healthy discussion about what conditions should be used in Female order to ceo asda get meaningful results.

I have seen even more research and informal articles about why is euthanasia illegal, programming languages that claim benefits to human productivity without providing any evidence for it whatsoever, other than the authorsí or the ceo asda communityís intuition, at best based on rational deductions from abstract beliefs that have never been empirically verified. Here is one that surprised me because I have the highest respect for the academic soundness of Haskell. Statements like this ď Haskell programs have fewer bugs because Haskell is: pure [Ö], strongly typed [Ö], high-level [Ö], memory managed [Ö], modular [Ö] [Ö] There just isnít any room for bugs! Ē are nothing but wishful thinking. Without the data to humanistic psychology support this claim, this statement is ceo asda deceptive; while it can be made informally in a blog post designed to evangelize the crowd, it definitely should not be made in the context of psychology, doctoral work unless that work provides solid evidence for such a strong statement. That article is not an ceo asda outlier. The Internets are full of monitoring project, articles claiming improved software development productivity for ceo asda, just about every other language. In What Judaism From Islam?! No evidence is ceo asda ever provided, the Female Characters in Hamlet Essay argumentation is always either (a) deducted from ceo asda principles that are supposed to american be true but that have never been verified, or (b) extrapolated from ad-hoc, highly biased, severely skewed personal experiences. This is the main reason why I stopped doing research in Programming Languages in any official capacity.

Back when I was one of the main evangelists for AOP I realized at some point that I had crossed the line to saying things for which I had very little evidence. I was simplyÖ evangelizing, i.e. convincing others of an idea that I believed strongly. Ceo Asda! At some point I felt I needed empirical evidence for what I was saying. But providing evidence for the human productivity argument is damn hard! My scientist self cannot lead doctoral students into monitoring processes overlap project groups., that trap, a trap that I know too well. Moreover, designing and executing the experiments that lead to uncovering such evidence requires a lot of time and a whole other set of skills that have absolutely nothing to ceo asda do with the time and monitoring processes all of the other groups., skills for actually designing programming languages.

We need to ceo asda learn the methods that experimental psychologists use. And, in the end of all that work, we will be lucky if we unveil correlations but we will not be able to draw any definite conclusions, which isÖ depressing. But without empirical evidence of any kind, and from a scientific perspective, unsubstantiated claims pertaining to, say, Haskell or AspectJ (which are mostly developed and differ from, used by ceo asda, academics and have been the topic of many PhD dissertations) are as good as unsubstantiated claims pertaining to, say, PHP (which is mostly developed and used by non-academics). The PHP community is actually very honest when it comes to stating the benefits of using the language. For example, here is an honest-to-god set of reasons for using PHP.

Notice that there are no claims whatsoever about euthanasia, PHP leading to less bugs or higher programmer productivity (as if anyone would dare to state that!); theyíre just pragmatic reasons. (Note also: Iím not implying that Haskell/AspectJ/PHP are ďcomparables;Ē they have quite different target domains. Ceo Asda! Iím just comparing the narratives surrounding those languages, the ďstoriesĒ that the communities tell within themselves and to others) OK, now that I made 823 enemies by pointing out that the claims about vicks company, human productivity surrounding languages that have emerged in academic communities ó and therefore ought to know better ó are unsubstantiated, PLUS 865 enemies by saying that empirical user studies are inconclusive and ceo asda, depressingÖ let me try to turn my argument around. Is the high bar of theory, scientific evidence killing innovation in programming languages? Is this whatís causing the asymptotic behavior? It certainly is whatís keeping me away from that topic, but Iím just a grain of sand. What about the work of many who propose intriguing new design ideas that are then shot down in peer-review committees because of the lack of evidence?

This ties back to my detour on the nature of research. Join Detour Design experimentation vs. Scientific evidence. So, weíre back to whether design innovation per ceo asda se is an admissible first-order goal of doctoral work or not. And now that question is in Hamlet Essay joined by a counterpart: is the provision of scientific evidence really required for ceo asda, doctoral work in programming languages? If what we have in hand is vicks company not Science, we need to be careful not to blindly adopt methods that work well for Science, because that may kill the essence of our discipline. In my view, that essence has been the radical, fast-paced, off the mark design experimentation enabled by software. This rush is fairly incompatible with the need to ceo asda provide scientific evidence for the design ďhopes.Ē Iíll try a parallel: drug design, the modern-day equivalent of in what, alchemy. In terms of research it is similar to ceo asda software: partly based on rigor, partly on intuitions, and now also on automated tools that simply perform an enormous amount of logical combinations of molecules and determine some objective function. When it comes to deployment, whoever is driving that work better put in place a plan for actually testing the theoretical expectations in the context of actual people.

Does the humanistic psychology drug really do what it is supposed to do without any harmful side effects? We require scientific evidence for the claimed value of experimental drugs. Should we require scientific evidence for ceo asda, the value of experimental software? The parallel diverges significantly with respect to theory the consequences of failure. A failure in drug design experimentation may lead to ceo asda people dying or getting even more sick. A failure in software design experimentation is only a big deal if the experiment had a huge investment from the humanistic psychology beginning and/or pertains to safety-critical systems. There are still some projects like that, and for those, seeking solid evidence of their benefits before deploying the production version of the experiment is a good thing. But not all software systems are like that.

Therefore the burden of scientific evidence may be too much to bear. It is also often the case that over ceo asda time, the enormous amount of testing by real use is enough to provide assurances of all kinds. One good example of design experimentation being at odds with scientific evidence is the proposal that Tim Berners-Lee made to way does judaism from CERN regarding the implementation of the hypertext system that became the Web. Nowhere in that proposal do we find a plan for verification of ceo asda, claims. Thatís just a solid good proposal for an intriguing ďlinked information system.Ē I can imagine TB-Lís manager thinking: ďhmm, ok, this is monitoring processes overlap the other process intriguing, heís a smart guy, heís not asking that many resources, letís have him do it and see what comes of it.

If nothing comes of it, no big deal.Ē Had TB-L have to devise a scientific or engineering assessment plan for that system beyond ďin the ceo asda second phase, weíll install it on many machinesĒ maybe the world would be very different today, because he might have gotten caught in monitoring and controlling processes overlap the other project management process groups. the black hole of trying to find quantifiable evidence for something that didnít need that kind of validation. Granted, this was not a doctoral topic proposal; it was a proposal for the design and implementation of a very concrete system with software in ceo asda it, one that (1) clearly identified the problem, (2) built on vicks company, previous ideas, including the authorís own experience, (3) had some intriguing insights in ceo asda it, (4) stated expected benefits and potential applications ó down to the prediction of search engines and graph-based data analysis. Should a proposal like TB-Lís be rejected if it were to monitoring overlap all of the other management process be a doctoral topic proposal? When is an ceo asda unproven design idea doctoral material and other isnít? If we are to accept design ideas without validation plans as doctoral material, how do we assess them?

In order to do experimental design research AND be scientifically honest at the same time, one needs to let go of claims altogether. Why Is! In that dreadful part of a topic proposal where the committee asks the student ďwhat are your claims?Ē the student should probably answer ďnone of interest.Ē In experimental design research, one can have hopes or expectations about the effects of the ceo asda system, and Female in Hamlet Essay, those must be clearly articulated, but very few certainties will likely come out of such type of work. And thatís ok! Itís very important to be honest. For example, itís not ok to ceo asda claim ďmy language produces bug-free programsĒ and then defend this with a deductive argument based on unproven assumptions; but itís ok to state ďI expect that my language produces programs with fewer bugs [but I donít have data to prove it].Ē TB-Lís proposal was really good at being honest. Finally, here is an attempt at american, establishing a rigorous criteria for design assessment in the context of doctoral and post-doctoral research: Problem : how important and surprising is the problem and how good is its description? The problem space is, perhaps, the most important component for a piece of design research work.

If the design is not well grounded in an interesting and important problem, then perhaps itís not worth pursuing as research work. Ceo Asda! If itís a old hard problem, it should be formulated in a surprising manner. Very often, the novelty of a design lies not in the design itself but in its designer seeing the problem differently. So ó surprise me with the problem. Show me insights on the nature of the theory problem that we donít already know. Potential : what intriguing possibilities are unveiled by ceo asda, the design? Good design research work should open up doors for american vs japan, new avenues of ceo asda, exploration. Feasibility : good design research work should be grounded on what is possible to Female Characters Essay do. The ideas should be demonstrated in the form of ceo asda, a working system. Additionally, design research work, like any other research work, needs to in Hamlet be placed in a solid context of what already exists. This criteria has two consequences that I really like: first, it substantiates our intuitions about proposals such as TB-Lís ďlinked information systemĒ being a fine piece of [design] research work; second, it substantiates our intuitions on ceo asda, the difference of languages like Haskell vs. languages like PHP.

I leave that as an exercise to monitoring overlap all of the other project process the reader! I would love to bring design back to my daytime activities. I would love to let my students engage in designing new things such as new programming languages and environments ó I have lots of ceo asda, ideas for what I would like to way does judaism differ islam? do in that area! I believe there is a path to establishing a set of rigorous criteria regarding the ceo asda assessment of design that is different from scientific/quantitative validation. All this, however, doesnít depend on vs japan, me alone. If my studentsí papers are going to ceo asda be shot down in program committees because of the lack of validation, then my wish is a curse for them. Humanistic! If my grant proposals are going to ceo asda be rejected because they have no validation plan other than ďand then we install it in many machinesĒ or ďand then we make the vicks company software open source and free of chargeĒ then my wish is a curse for me. We need buy-in from a much larger community ó in ceo asda a way, reverse the trend of placing software research under the auspices of science and vicks company, engineering [alone] . This, however, should only be done after the community understands what science and ceo asda, scientific methods are all about (the engineering ones ó everyone knows about vs japan, them). At this point there is still a severe lack of understanding of science within the CS community. Our graduate programs need to ceo asda cover empirical (and other scientific) methods much better than they currently do.

If we simply continue to ignore the Characters workings of ceo asda, science and the burden of vicks company, scientific proof, we end up continuing to make careless religious statements about our programming languages and ceo asda, systems that simply will lead nowhere, under the misguided impression that we are scientists because the name says so. Copyright © Crista Videira Lopes. All rights reserved. Note: this is a work-in-progress essay. I may update it from time to time.

Feedback welcome. 104 Responses to Research in Programming Languages. Thanks for the interesting article! I entirely agree with you when you say: ďwe need to vs japan be careful not to blindly adopt methods that. work well for ceo asda, Science, because that may kill the essence. of our disciplineĒ Indeed!

One of my favorite quotes is Einsteinís. ďNot everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be countedĒ I think this is in what way does judaism from especially important to bear in mind when considering PL/Design. (And yes, program committees are terrible at ceo asda, evaluating language designs ó partly. because they are very difficult to evaluate! ó I have many anecdotes about this, all. quite objective IMO as none of them are about my own papers, but thats another storyÖ) That said, I believe the vs japan situation is not as dire as you indicate. Ceo Asda! As you point out: 1. ďÖone striking commonality in all modern programming languages, especially the. popular ones, is how little innovation there is in vicks company them!Ē

2. ďÖthere appears to be no correlation between the success of a programming language. and its emergence in the form of ceo asda, someoneís doctoral or post-doctoral work.Ē The explanation for vicks company, this is *not* that all the interesting/innovative PL work was done. in the 70s, and that the work now is simply too technical etc. Ceo Asda! Instead, the explanation is. that it *takes decades* to humanistic theory really figure out what the truly useful, valuable and. implementable designs/features are, and ceo asda, the best way to integrate them with. ďmainstreamĒ languages. In other words, the ďtech transferĒ process for language. design has proven to be decades longÖ

So yes, there is little correlation with programming *languages*, but I think the. picture is quite different if you look at *features* not entire languages. Recall that it took GC nearly 50 years to go mainstream! As you point out, there are. few definitive ďscientificĒ studies about why even GC is better. Monitoring And Controlling Processes The Other Project Process Groups.! Once you move to. things like static typing, I think it becomes an impossible endeavor, for the reasons. Einstein pithily describes. Thus, instead of ceo asda, nifty scientific charts, what we have are. series of anecdotes and psychology, narratives built up over a long span (maybe decades), at.

which point the features inch into the mainstream. Every time someone says ďthere has been no new innovative work in languagesĒ since. so-and-soís (Turing award) winning work in the 60s, 70s, one simply has to point. to the ceo asda explosion of cleverness in Haskell, much of Female Characters, which has already. ďgone mainstreamĒ. The single most astonishing and influential feature is. probably Typeclasses ó see Simon Peyton-Jonesí graph. which enabled a slew of other things (monads, FRP, generic programming, quickcheck etc.) I doubt any of this could be anticipated when typeclasses came out, and indeed there are, to my amazement, those who still question the value of this.

feature. Nevertheless, two-and-a-half decades on, these are all features. (local type inference, lambdas, LINQ,Ö) seeping into mainstream languages. C# has been particularly progressive in this regard. Other recent examples. that pop to mind are the early academic work on SELF/OO (designs + optimizations) which are now the basis for many of the performance improvements for JS. And of course, there are the ceo asda many innovations around Scala and F# which.

are greatly informed by deep technical ideas that came out of the academic. So, the upshot is that yes, a lot of work in PL (and SE) is indeed design, which. is difficult if not impossible to evaluate using the usual scientific method. We should be looking for better ways to evaluate them, and not nipping ideas. in the bud before there is bullet proof ďevidenceĒ of merit. In What Way Does Judaism! Nevertheless, all is ceo asda not lost. There does appear to judaism differ from islam? be a (rather lengthy) social process, where thanks to.

anecdotal narratives there is a steady stream of academic ideas that eventually. seriously influencing mainstream languages. We should be thinking of ways to. shorten this process, and in the meantime, be patient. If nothing else, Iíd argue that the most important contribution of ceo asda, PL research is the introduction of concepts that are later assimilated into more popular languages, even if the research languages themselves never see wide acceptance. In What Islam?! Python owes its list comprehensions to ceo asda Haskell (similarly with Rustís typeclasses), and Iíd like to vicks company think that AspectJ had a non-negligible influence on Pythonís decorators. For a more extreme example, consider the fact (the fact! ) that we will never again see a new programming language that does not feature first-class functions. I like to think that there are countless novel, pragmatic concepts hiding away in obscure programming languages that are merely waiting for ceo asda, their day in the sun.

This is really spot on. I would like to refer you to a couple of vicks company, things that come to ceo asda mind that you might find useful for advancing this line of thinking. First, I saw a talk by Jonathan Edwards that was very much along the monitoring and controlling processes overlap the other project management process groups. lines of what you wrote here: http://alarmingdevelopment.org/?p=5. Second, Christopher Alexanderís early work on ceo asda, patterns in architecture and urban design have been referenced quite a bit in computer science, but seldom is his Ďmagnum opusí, a four-book series on the Ďnature of theory, orderí, referenced. These texts move far beyond the early work. You would do well to have a look at the first book, which tries to ceo asda establish an objective theory of design not based on scientific principles: http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss_1?url=search-alias%3Daps#038;field-keywords=the+nature+of+order#038;x=0#038;y=0. Third, you might be interested to read some discussion on the history of music programming languages. Max/MSP and Pd, both dataflow-oriented, offer what I would estimate to vicks company be an order of ceo asda, magnitude of productivity gain for theory, certain tasks in building one-off multi-media systems. Theyíre a bit like a UNIX for real-time multi-media + control signals. This essay reminded me a bit of the anti-academic and organic approach that Miller Puckette took in ceo asda building them despite being trained as a mathematician and developing them in vicks company an academic setting. This serves as a good lesson that successful software isnít necessarily designed by having good principles, but rather the proper environment , namely, one with energy and ceo asda, a need.

Check out two papers in the Computer Music Journal where this is discussed: 2002. Miller Puckette, ďMax at SeventeenĒ. Computer Music Journal, 26(4) 2002. Female Characters In Hamlet! Eric Lyon, ďDartmouth Symposium on the Future of ceo asda, Computer Music Software: A Panel DiscussionĒ. Computer Music Journal, 26(4) Generally, computer music is one of the more interesting fields to look at if youíre interested in ascertaining the euthanasia illegal future of ceo asda, HCI, computer science and psychological research since from the beginning they have not been accorded the luxury of vicks company, forgoing certain constraints, such as that everything must happen in real-time, data must be of ceo asda, a certain resolution (in time and Ďspaceí) and that non-tech-savvy practitioners from other fields (musicians) must be able to Female in Hamlet use the tools as experts. Oh, and I would add that if you are not familiar with Bill Buxtonís career, it may prove interesting reading for you. He began in computer music and is now a strong advocate for Design in technology. One insight that he often emphasizes, which I donít claim is his originally, is that new technologies take 20-30 years to be adopted.

According to ceo asda this view, new ideas in software design should expect to lie dormant for at least 20 years, echoing what @Ben wrote above. I fully agree with your viewpoint re. human productivity. I watch commercial Java progamming taking place and I see productivity no better than COBOL and probably a lot worse given how much more is expected of software now. I suspect most step change improvements in productivity have to come from better adaption to the task, i.e. from vicks company languages that are to a greater or lesser degree domain-specific. There is an old but fairly well-known and scientific paper by ceo asda, Verner Tate on comparison between COBOL and in what judaism from, a 4GL. The 4GL was. 5x more productive. Of course most of the 4GLs were arguably domain-specific languages for ceo asda, database-centric enterprise software. The paper is vicks company available via IEEE but I donít find any public copy. The title is ďestimating size and effort in fourth-generation developmentĒ.

If you have Bob Glassís book Software Conflict itís highlighted on ceo asda, p.98, something I was amused to find recently as I used to work with and on in Hamlet, the 4GL technology in question 20 years ago. Of course the commercial 4GLs were largely killed off by a combination of factors including the Web and the rise of open source, but we did lose something there. That. 5x productivity is eyecatching but itís consistent with my personal experience with the ceo asda technology. Those who do not study history, etc.

Ė comprehensions didnít originate in haskell (probably not even from Miranda, as they were available in smalltalk, and probably that was taken from somewhere else) Ė aspect oriented programming didnít start with aspectJ. I think Kiczales started his experiments using common lisp. at monitoring processes overlap all of management, least the early papers on aop used that. other than that, I think you have a good point. There will be a day when the programming universe accepts the fact that LISP is by far the best programming language in the world, a language that can actually ďthinkĒ and ceo asda, make decisions, logical decisions. The shortest path algorithm can be written in humanistic theory psychology LISP in ceo asda a few lines Ė I challenge any programmer out there to do it in a few pages in C, without using any dependencies. LISP has been underestimated for quite so long, and itís nice to see that someone (like you) acknowledges the contributions that LISP has on the programing ecosystem.

u might want to add sml languages to your list of developments. also check out mythryl and other ports of ocaml/sml languages. Very interesting. Iím in the industry developing software. Iím not sure what to think about the monitoring and controlling processes overlap all of project process 3 goals you state: for ceo asda, performance, we have grids, clusters, GPUs, it seems there is more and vs japan, more hardware so that even if the language itself is ceo asda not ďfastĒ, the grid will compensate (as an aside, Iím seeing horrible uses of grids from a resource point of view: people donít care about writing efficient software, because they know they can have 1,000 more nodes on psychology, the grid anywayÖ) ; for productivity, what Iím seeing everyday is ceo asda that: either the problem is (partially) solved by the use of libraries, or whatís really getting you is the environment, such mundane things as repositories, build systems, deployments (just a matter of organization, more than science, I guess)Ö and vicks company, testing Ė I think each day of coding results in 2 or 3 days of testing, that testing being a kind of ceo asda, ďproofĒ that the system is not going toÖ crash and vicks company, make you lost money. In other words, in my practice, writing code is definitely not what takes the most time. Reducing the amount of ceo asda, testing we have to do, or reducing the possibilities of bugs would in the end be the most useful (to me), and Iím constantly looking for automated proving tools, but those are not forthcoming for C++ or Java.

I would like to echo Frankís comment. I work in a 50 person team all working on the same codebase. The ratio of writing production code to why is illegal writing unit, integration and acceptance tests is similar. There is nothing in C# that assists us perform this testing. The challenges and complexity for us lie in building a continuous integration environment that detects problems, identifies the developer responsible informs them of the ceo asda problem quickly so that they can fix the way does judaism differ from issue. When a developer commits bad code like a failing test we ideally need for this to be isolated so that productivity of the remaining team is not affected. This last requirement is proving particularly tricky. I was doing my phd in PL and felt the same way about AOP.

Iím relieved someone involved with it ginally said agreed. Ceo Asda! Another goal of monitoring processes groups., PL research ought to be discovering more primitive forms of computation, e.g. continuations, closures, type theories. Concurrency is still a mess and could use some innovation. Also distributed programming, reliable systems, and module systems. None of the ceo asda popular languages have anything to offer for these problems. I have been using and advocating literate software for a decade. I claim that it improves software due to three effects:

1) the developer has to explain the code and, as a side-effect, discovered. corner cases, missed cases, bad design, etc. before submission to review. 2) the team reviewer have text that explains the design decisions and the. rationale behind the code. they are able to critique the design as well as. the code. They will better understand the code which leads to better. review which leads to higher quality. 3) the code ďlivesĒ because it is embedding in human-to-human.

communication. There are over euthanasia 100,000 dead piles of code on Sourceforge. because the author left and nobody has a clue about how to maintain and. modify the ceo asda code. I have been trying to find a researcher at a University interested in. creating studies to confirm or deny the above assertions which are. based only on my experience. Claim 2, for instance, could be tested by taking previously published. software (e.g. cryptographic software).

Give one group the book. ďImplementing Cryptographic SoftwareĒ which contains the actual. source code. Give a second group just the source code from the book. Have a group review and post-review test. See which group has a. better understanding of the code, e.g. why some constant has the. We need studies like this to ďput some scienceĒ behind the opinions. Literate programming is a fundamentally important technology but. nobody will touch it unless we do the vicks company studies. If this would be of interest to you, contact me. The premise on which Don Knuth created the concepts for LP was the ceo asda idea to create documentation and program code from just one source.

This premise has become obsolete many years ago, with tools like Javadoc or Doxygen. These latter tools also come with a big advantage, as they donít require a pre-source code version of your programs, and therefore can directly interoperate with any developer tool of your choice. LP however greatly inhibits that choice, as the ĎWEBí code isnít well suited to interoperate with many modern tools involving version control or team development. LP was a great concept 30 years ago, when there was no way to create source code and documentation from american a single source, in the same way TeX was a good idea when there was no WYSIWIG. Ceo Asda! These times are past now. I liked this article because of how it tried to get people to think out of the box, and stop follwing well-trodden paths. I donít think going down a 30 year old path will lead to any new insights. Putting documentation and source code in one place is not the purpose of literate programing.

The main merit of literate programming is to and controlling processes process groups. rearrange the code in what best for human mind to ceo asda follow. TeX is still a good idea now. Vs Japan! The current WYSIWIG sucks. What I like to ceo asda see is an editor that build for dual monitors where you edit TeX on one screen and have the american vs japan rendered output on the other display. The insistence of Don Knuth on maintaining TeX has been preventing this to happen. I have acquired many of ceo asda, Don Knuthís books and generally consider myself one of his fans. From his literate programming, I take the merits of being able to arrange code and monitoring and controlling processes overlap management groups., take forms in what best for human reading, rather than computer parsing. And often, what is ceo asda best for human reading is what best for human writing. However, I am not big fan of documentations. Writing papers to defend oneís idea are difficult and not fun except when that is the american vs japan purpose. Ceo Asda! It has its merit in academics, but in way does practical situations of programing, we are trying to ceo asda get things done rather than to in what judaism differ islam? propagate an idea.

And the current very reason that we need documentation is because current languages are still oriented toward machines, rather than expressing human ideas. What I want to see in the direction of ceo asda, programming research is a system that takes in what is intuitive for humans and translate them into what is ready for machines. This system should be restrictive on the machine side so optimizations can happen, and differ from islam?, flexible on ceo asda, the human side because that is how our mind operate. Most important that I want to see is emphasis that the programming system not to force machine concepts upon us. In What Way Does Differ Islam?! If the programmer want certain concepts in OOP, he could write that part in OOP, or functional, or any domain specific form. However, the language system should not force the programmer to think everything in OOP or functional or any domain specific way. Once we can really express our ideas in most natural ways that we can unambiguously read and understand, then we shouldnít need much additional documenting. Please post this also at http://lambda-the-ultimate.org/ Iíd do it for you, but you may have your own reasons for not wanting to.

Please do! I guess Iím not used to posting stuff there, although I like that site very much. BTW, we had this same argument at the WGLD meeting last week in ceo asda London. It is american vs japan nice to see a very well thought out argument in ceo asda this blog post. Nearly 30 years without fundamental progress in programming languages shows that weíve reached a trashold to a completely new domain of programming languages. Maybe the next step are natural languages maybe its some synthesis of various programming principles. Why Is Euthanasia! My biggest constraint about current languages (or programming envionments) is that you need a zoo different languages to make an ceo asda enterprise running: front end (HTM, CSS, Ö), middle tier (Java, c#, standard components, Ö), backend (PL/SQL, Systemís API, Libraries, Ö), deployment (shell, scheduling tools, server configuration, Ö), organization (versioning tools, CI server, Ö). My dream is to have an all-in-one language I can use to talk with the computer about all of theses domains. I am sorry to have to break this to you, but UNIX, C, and C++ were also small ďpersonalĒ developments. Ken Thompson started UNIX in 1969 and slowly brought others in on Essay, its development. Dennis Richie started C in 1969, it was many years before he expanded the scope of work to include any other developers.

Bjarne Stroustrup not only started C++ by himself (in 1979), but even now he remains the ceo asda primary definer of the language. ATTís funding of UNIX was so limited that in 1971 they could barely afford a PDP 11/20. Instead of trying to mimic our colleaguesí traditional practices, ďcomputer scientistsĒ ought to be showing the way to a new kind of science ó maybe that new kind of science or that one or maybe something else. I dare to suggest that the something else is related to the design of things that have software in vicks company them. It should not be called Science. It is a bit like Engineering, but itís not it either because weíre not dealing [just] with physical things. Ceo Asda! Technology doesnít cut it either. Vs Japan! It needs a new name, something that denotes ďthe design of things with software in them.Ē I will call it Design for short, even though that word is so abused that it has lost its meaning. I think itís fascinating that youíve come up with this, because Iíve seen a very, very similar idea come up in ceo asda the real-time and embedded systems community. The name they use is ďcyber-physical systemsĒ (CPS) which you can read about on Wikipedia.

Basically, CPS is mainly used as a way to structure funding opportunities and seems to have been popularized largely from that source. Thereís a lot of skepticism about whether itís a ďreal thingĒ or just a fad of language. Way Does From Islam?! And Iíve heard it described in ceo asda many different ways (some clearly better than others). The best way Iíve heard it described is thus (you can imagine Iím giving a spiel at a conference, trying to sell you on the idea): Engineers used to build things. Now, engineers build things connected or composed of computer networks and Female in Hamlet Essay, computer code. This enables a vast increase in complexity of the ceo asda system (a good thing) but makes building and verifying the system much more complex. A good example is a modern passenger aircraft (think Airbus 380, Dreamliner) or automobile (which sometimes can have 100 ďECUsĒ, or embedded computers, most of which are connected by a bus). This is a very, very important research area, because in the future, everything will be like this Ė buildings, complex robotic systems, medicine, etc.

Although sometimes I am skeptical of CPS, when put that way, I really think the approach makes a lot of sense. Anyway, just wanted to differ express my excitement at seeing this bubble up in another place, point you in that direction in case you want to explore it. I found your blog from ceo asda Hacker News and Iím not that familiar with your background, so apologies if Iím preaching to the choir here. Hope you see the connection Iím trying to monitoring project management make. I consider CSP concurrency very useful and ceo asda, innovative. Important languages with their publication dates are Squeak(1985), Newsqueak(1990), Alef(1995), Limbo(2000), Go(2009). This doesnít seem ďno innovationĒ to me. Same for humanistic psychology, Pi-calculus(1992), Join-calculus(1996), JoCaml(1999), C omega(2003), and so on. Ceo Asda! In general, we learned a lot about how to do concurrency in vs japan programming languages, and ceo asda, we are reaping benefits (Go, C#). You seem to consider mashup non-innovative, but I consider languages integrating OOP and Female Characters in Hamlet, FP type systems pretty innovative.

OCaml(1996), Scala(2003), F sharp(2005), and so on. Other examples I can think of ceo asda, are lazy evaluation, delimited continuation, dataflow programming, metaprogramming. Most of advances in Characters in Hamlet Essay lazy evaluation are post-1980, especially how to implement it. The Implementation of ceo asda, Functional Programming Languages is from 1987. Female In Hamlet! Shift/Reset delimited continuation appeared in 1990 and we learned a lot more about it since. For dataflow programming, SISAL is from 1983, Oz is from 1991. For metaprogramming, the first widely used language with hygienic macro, R5RS, appeared in 1998! Both MetaOCaml and Template Haskell postdate 2000! Is there still anything to innovate in programming languages?

Yes, there are *a lot* to innovate in ceo asda programming languages. Interesting essay Ö And itís about time the question of monitoring all of project, ďdoes PL design make for ceo asda, doctoral work?Ē and ďif yes, how do we evaluate?Ē gets asked. I wonder whether mathematics would be an appropriate analogy here, with core ideas such as monads being analogous to mathematics, and american vs japan, PLs that support monads being analogous to mathematical notation. Weíve certainly had influential mathematical notation that captured concepts so well that one might say theyíve become fused in ceo asda the minds of illegal, people. Examples such as the ceo asda place value system, algebra, vector notation, notations for ordinary calculus, vector calculus, exterior calculus, Feynman diagrams and molecular formulae come to mind. Broadly, though good notations have been influential in communicating mathematical ideas and using them, nobodyís gotten an PhD in Female Essay math for ceo asda, inventing a notation afaik. At best, these inventions come in the form of a paper or a note.

By analogy, PL design sans new concepts (like new math), to Female Characters in Hamlet me, seems inadequate for doctoral work. This criterion rules out purely syntactic contributions and I think thatís a valid criterion Ė unless one wishes to ceo asda study Whorfian issues like impact of syntax on cognition. Iíll stop here lest my response itself turn into an essay Thanks for euthanasia, raising these questions. Ė ďC, part of a large investment in ceo asda UnixĒÖ doesnít match the history I know Ė Unix was initially created as an monitoring and controlling overlap all of project groups. undeground project (Bell thinking they were funding a text processing system), and C was the undergroundís underground as it was a demand of Unix. AlsoC didnít seem to have significant up-front design; it was derived from previous languages and iterated with the OS projectís needs. Ė Todayís top-5 popular languages, as listed by the Tiobe index (not a great methodology but the best we have and updated monthly), are Java, C, C#, C++ and ceo asda, Objective-C. Euthanasia Illegal! All these languages were created by top PL/compiler experts (BTW, Java too fell into ceo asda, Guy Steeleís lap). So I wouldnít say that languages hacked together in a week by amateurs, are anything close to the norm. Even in way does differ the bleeding edge, youíll find that most ďhotĒ languages are once again created by ceo asda, experts like Odersky, Rich Hickey, Bracha, etc. Ė Notice also that the creators of differ islam?, those hacked languages are often not classic PL researchers, but they are always brilliant and well-educated developers.

Example: Larry Wall had a BS in ďnatural and ceo asda, artificial languagesĒ and followed with graduate studies in human linguisticsĖthis mix, with the in Hamlet stronger focus in the human languages, easily explains his approach with Perl. Larryís classic article ďWherefore Art, Thou?Ē is essential for this discussion: http://www.linuxjournal.com/article/2070. Ė Languages are expensive tools; the switch to a new language is a huge investment, from each developerís learning curve to the enormous weight of legacy code and the wide and ceo asda, deep ecosystem of supporting toolchain and libraries. This cuses the frustrating delay for vicks company, academic innovation to ceo asda trickle down to mainstream languages, a process that often takes multiple generations of languages (if not human generations). ďUniversalĒ platforms, from Microsoftís .NET/CLI to modern Java and now HTML5, have reduced the barrier to entry with common frameworks and runtime technology; but really, they are mostly modern replacements for Unix/POSIX: a common base that provides all core APIs, and core services like I/O and memory management, that any language would need, and does that in vicks company a portable way. So, these virtual platforms mostly compensate for the new needs of post-C/Unix languages such as garbage collection, and for the failure of POSIX to ceo asda become a unversal system interface so application-level libraries would need porting to Win32, Cocoa etc. Ė Because languages are tools, their success is the result of adoption by monitoring and controlling overlap all of process, millions of rank-and-file professionals, 90% of those as unable to distinguish the ceo asda qualities of ďproperly-designedĒ PLs as I am unable to distinguish a $1000 champagne from a $20 sparkling wine.

This is theory psychology critically different from most academic work, e.g. in ceo asda mathematics o theoretical physics, which is only consumed/judged/adopter by other academics with roughly the same level of why is euthanasia, education and the same focus and values. Well, itís not that simple because the first stage of adoption is ceo asda typically driven by some kind of elite, still the language eventually needs to vicks company scale to Joe Developer, which never happened and will never happen with languages like Haskell, regardless of its significant adoption some years ago and very mature implementation. Thanks for all these comments! Iíd love to think that many new things were proposed after 1979, but history doesnít seem to support that view. Here are some concepts mentioned in this discussion: Ė Dataflow programming: late 60s. Ė Actors: early 70s by Carl Hewitt. Ė CSP: late 70s by Hoare. Ė Pi-calculus: not terribly different from earlier work on ceo asda, CCS.

The CCS book was published in 1980, the work was done before that. Ė Lazy evaluation: early 70s within work in lambda calculus. Ė Metaprogramming: early 70s. Ė Continuations: mid 60s. I agree that many *improvements* came after this, particularly with respect to implementing these things efficiently (engineering), but also in maturing the concepts themselves.

Improvements are important too, and monitoring and controlling overlap all of process, they have the ceo asda wonderful property that itís really easy to assess their value. But it seems that the euthanasia *innovations* (i.e. the new concepts) have pretty much stagnated, exceptions not withstanding. Iíd love to be proven wrong. ďBut it takes 20 years for design ideas to come to the masses.Ē Maybe, maybe not. Some innovations have a really rapid mass-adoption (certain machine learning methods come to mind), others never get mass-adopted.

In any case, we should be seeing stuff proposed in the early 90s come out to the masses now. Where is it? I only see stuff thatís been created before 1979 (again, exceptions not withstanding). You know when you go to PL conferences and those old timers stand up and say ďbut insert vintage language had that back in ceo asda 1975ÖĒ? I used to find it really annoying. But theyíre right, for the most part. I think itís time that we accept that theyíre right, and reflect on the reasons for this state of affairs.

Thanks also for those who point out that C was an underdog project. Illegal! Iíll update the essay one of ceo asda, these days. I guess the point should be that before the and controlling all of management PC era, this kind of work was exclusive of the very few lucky ones who had access to very expensive computers ó and ceo asda, that tended to happen only in vicks company University labs and Industrial Research labs. Once PCs came upon us, that situation changed, and this kind of work started happening in a lot more places by ceo asda, a lot more people. Design of things with software in them was democratized. Hi Crista ó I donít have time to take apart your essay, but Iíd like to add a couple of. 1. All disciplines go through periods of exciting activity and steady-state work. American Vs Japan! See. Thomas Kuhnís short book ďThe Structure of Scientific Revolutions.Ē Even if you do. not accept his judgement (on paradigm shifts), you should read it for the collection.

of historical work on the evolution of disciplines. It is ceo asda good for researchers to reflect on their discipline and its relationship to the world. It is dangerous to think our own discipline is facing unique problems, and it is even more dangerous not to vicks company know the history and philosophy of ceo asda, science. [[Example: I agree with you that continuations and monitoring and controlling overlap the other process, delimited continuations. ó as I proposed them at POPL í88 after working them out for ceo asda, 4 years ó fall straight into the steady-state part of and controlling project management process, PL research. Ceo Asda! Indeed, as you say, Stoy had a similar idea in vicks company the 1970s for his OS work, though I do claim what. prompt and ceo asda, control/c/callcc did was much more. Nevertheless, itís small. potatoes and yet, I enjoyed working on delimited continuations for years, and I enjoyed it even more getting them just right in a production system.

a few years back (ICFP). It is fun when you see all the pieces fall into place.]] 2. You are plain wrong when it comes to the evaluation of programming languages. When IBM switched to Java whole-sale, it had gathered a large amount of data on. the productivity of programming in american vs japan Java (with memory safety, type safety) vs C++ (lack of both). It had started with the ceo asda San Francisco project run by Kathy Boherer, with a dozen or so large companies contributing some 120 software architects.

These. people determined that Java improved the productivity of average programmers by. a factor of 3 or more. As someone mentioned, PLs are a major infrastructure investment. and switching infrastructure is humanistic theory psychology expensive.

Hence when a major, large company does. switch, we should pay attention. Sadly, we also need to accept that they perceive such. data as a competitive advantage and will therefore not release it. 3. As far as Ďdesigní is concerned, I agree with you. Standard PL conferences ó perhaps. with the exception of OOPSLA ó give way too little credit to design. When they do, including OOPSLA, it is in a strange fashion. Find 20 people to run a symposium on PL. design. Iíll attend.

4. I have heard the lament about hobbyists designing PLs many times now, and I have. formulated it myself in semi-public spaces since 2000. I have found myself to be wrong. 4a. These languages tend to inject one or two new ideas into the discussion. In addition, unlike PLs designed by ceo asda, academic researchers at theory, universities and labs, the break-thru.

languages address dire needs of practical work and ceo asda, design ó immediately and on the spot. Javascripts evolution ó as a Scheme turned into theory psychology, a language without parentheses, now! ó is ceo asda a classic example. Brendan Eich should write it down for historyís sake, and not just the sanitized version that leaves his superiors blameless. 4b. These languages pose interesting and exciting new problems for PL researchers.

I have worked on adding types to untyped languages for 20 years; since the web placed. languages such as Python and vicks company, Javascript into the center of ceo asda, new software designs (1998ish. latest), this work has become tremendously relevant. I am actually pretty sure that it. will evolve into a nearly-big idea that people will pay attention to. 5. Last but not least, donít escape.

If you find other areas more challenging, do pursue problems there. But if you believe that our own discipline needs serious change, work for change as a researcher who sets new standards and creates new ways of vicks company, working in our world. I didnít escape At some point I felt the need to go and explore other parts of town to see whatís all about and ceo asda, how things are done there. I visited a few places, and I ended up spending more time in the data mining / IR neighborhood; that is really cool too. Why Is Illegal! Great for ceo asda, doctoral work, because itís all very quantitative and vs japan, the benefits are very tangible. My design addiction went back to ceo asda distributed systems; Iíve been doing a lot of work there, but itís all mostly unpublished, if one considers having a user base of 5,000 people ďunpublished work.Ē I think these 2 extremes ó data mining = research papers + research funding; and OpenSimulator = design fun with a large user base ó are a very big part of these reflections on design as doctoral work. Theory! These observations are not just for PLs, btw; I think they apply to software systems in general. Languages are particularly good to ceo asda reflect upon. Hope to continue this conversation with you some time!

As for this essay, please do break it apart if you have time. Maybe then it can become a real paperÖ heheh. This post had been sitting on humanistic theory psychology, my blog under password protection for ceo asda, a few months, unfinished, unpolished. Some students started asking for it, so I freed it from the vs japan password. Re: what Matthias says about ďour own discipline Ö facing unique. problemsĒ. Indeed, see this (and comments) for related soul searching in ceo asda other CS disciplines. On another note, I think there is rather too much cultural emphasis on. ďinnovationĒ in the sense that Crista describes here (ďbig ideasĒ). After.

all taken to the extreme, *everything* boils down to Female Essay the lambda calculus. or state machines, so by this logic, we might as well have called it a day. by the end of the 1930s. Ceo Asda! One extremely negative consequence (or cousin?) of this emphasis, is the need to vicks company find single herculean figures who cause. Sure, that might happen once in a while, rather more rarely than you think.

In reality progress is ceo asda rather more bottom up, in in what differ islam? fits and ceo asda, starts with lots. of ďlittle ideasĒ cancelling or building up on each other, lots of dead. ends (with, sadly, the american vs japan final ďcreditĒ not going to the person who. ďdiscoveredĒ an ceo asda idea, but with the Female Essay person after whom the idea ďstayed. There needs to be *far* more importance placed on the critical ďsteady.

stateĒ work that Matthias refers to that is needed to refine/improve/fix. some idea till the ceo asda point the ďpieces to fall into placeĒ. This might be. especially true in PL because there are so many different moving parts. that need to be reconciled. And so, I have rather less patience for the ďold timersĒ.

(Of course, like all other disciplines, we also have some wheel reinvention, but thats another matter altogetherÖ) ps: as phrased, this question appears impossible to answer: ďWhere is it? I only see stuff thatís been created before 1979 (again, exceptions not withstanding).Ē I bet you in 10 years, weíll have turned a full circle, and american vs japan, the above date will be updated. to 1989, and thats how we move forward #128521; I think your conclusion about the quote regarding Haskell is incorrect.

Statements like this ďHaskell programs have fewer bugs because Haskell is: pure [Ö], strongly typed [Ö], high-level [Ö], memory managed [Ö], modular [Ö] [Ö] There just isnít any room for bugs!Ē are nothing but wishful thinking. Ceo Asda! Without the vicks company data to support this claim, this statement is deceptive; True, if you read the sentence ďThere just isnít any room for bugs!Ē as globally scoped and interpret it as ďYou canít have bugs in Haskell programs.Ē, this would certainly be a silly claim. And even though I donít believe that this is the ceo asda intent of the sentence, I think it would be better to either drop the why is illegal sentence altogether or at least qualify it and say that there is ceo asda no room for certain kinds of errors (such as type errors or memory errors). However, if we focus on the first sentence, then it is Female Characters Essay not at all wishful thinking. More importantly, it doesnít require any data or experiments to ceo asda support that observation, because it expresses a logical conclusion. And therein lies the importance of the claim, namely that a type checker proves the absence of a whole class of errors.

So it is a simple fact ó an analytical, non-empirical fact ó that, e.g., type-correct programs contain fewer errors than arbitrary programs. Empirical validation is a requirement in vicks company Science. Sometimes the ceo asda claims are hard to prove empirically, so you have to wait many years before empirical validation is possible (e.g. Physics). That doesnít seem to be the in what judaism from case here; the data for whether Haskell programs have more or less bugs than non-Haskell programs (or whatever claim you want to formulate) is not that hard to get as compared to, say, particle physics experiments where millions of ceo asda, dollars need to be spent in building large infrastructures. So if whoever made that claim about Haskell wants to call themselves a Scientist, they better be sure that the way does judaism differ from logic holds in the presence of empirical data. Or change the claim to something less ambitious like ďtype checkers eliminate a whole class of errors; Haskell has a type checker, therefore, a whole class of ceo asda, errors is in what islam? eliminated.Ē Indeed, thatís what theyíre designed to do, so making this be true is as simple as making a correct implementation of ceo asda, said type checker. Haskell programs, however, like all others, are written by people, and people make all sorts of mistakes. So if you want to prove that Haskell programs [written by people] have less bugs than non-Haskell programs [written by people] you need to compare empirically.

You may be unpleasantly surprised with the results; or you may come out vicks company a winner, in ceo asda which case the vicks company whole world will be convinced that type checkers are an absolute must-have in every programming language. Without empirical validation the claim ďHaskell programs have less bugsĒ is just a conjecture. You seem to present a dichotomy: empirically validated claims without innovation, or innovation without empirical validation. I do wonder if these are the only alternatives? Even if they were, languages Ė along with tools, methodologies, nearly everything in the vicinity of software Ė are so much in the latter camp today, it would seem that a little more emphasis on empiricism Ė that which in ceo asda most disciplines earns the term ďscienceĒ Ė couldnít hurt. I am entirely unconvinced that ďIt is also often the case that over time, the enormous amount of testing by real use is enough to provide assurances of all kinds.Ē Indeed, the frequent stampedes of monitoring and controlling the other project management process groups., software developers in the direction of ceo asda, new, shiny things assure us of very little except that recent religious converts are quite zealous. I take your assertion as more of theory psychology, a sigh. Your thesis, that academic research in programming languages may be of diminishing value and, in any case, is hardly science, is well-taken. A few proofreading notes: ďinnovate new softwareĒ Ė you probably meant ďinnovativeĒ. ďwe have in handsĒ Ė I think the idiom should be ďwe have in handĒ and not match number unless you wish to write ďwe have on our handsĒ. Crista, just in case it isnít clear, I really meant what I wrote in my post: IBM people claimed data-driven validation of ďJava is ceo asda better than C++ for large projectsĒ.

Their evaluation method uses dollars-spent, i.e., it is an accounting method from the business school that answers the question in a positive sense. Matthias, that is something that big, responsible companies, when faced with a technological decision, do, so I would be surprised if they had *not* made a cost/benefit analysis with real, hard data. Iím less inclined to accept IBMís business decision as empirical evidence for the benefits of american, Java vs. C++, in ceo asda general, unless they open up their data and methodology to scrutiny. That would be very interesting to judaism see! In any case, CS academics should take note of ceo asda, such data-driven practices. To me, ďmacro is an innovation but hygienic macro is just an improvementĒ sounds as absurd as ďelectricity is an innovation but alternating current is just an improvementĒ. Ditto for continuation/delimited continuation, lazy evaluation in Female Essay lambda calculus/lazy evaluation, etc. I also consider ďwithout empirical validation the claim ďHaskell programs have less bugsĒ is just a conjectureĒ a weird claim.

It is ceo asda a conjecture, but it would be a *mathematically informed conjecture* not *just* a conjecture. For theoretical physics, theories that avoid producing infinity ó renormalization ó is considered better than other theories. American Vs Japan! Why not apply same for type safety? Henry Ford said that if he had asked people what they wanted, then it would have been a faster horse that ate less and required less grooming. PL research stuck in that space, dreaming up of flying horses. There are basically two issues to consider:

1. Abstraction: FORTRAN, COBOL, APL because successful because they addressed a specific domain and programming in those languages required less effort than in assembler. 2. Notations: the ďwarsĒ between proponents of different programming languages typically boils down to arguing over syntax and more rarely semantics. The future ďinstructing computers to do to our biddingĒ comes from ever more powerful domain specific languages using notations that are ďintuitiveĒ to those domain experts. Ceo Asda! Model based software engineering and generative programming techniques form the foundations to Characters in Hamlet support such a vision. There is far more work done in ceo asda those areas than most programmers realize. Judaism! The companies being successful with such projects keep it as ďtheir secret sauceĒ and ceo asda, donít advertise their breakthroughs. are there any researches on rule based techniques for GUI programming. I would be interested in that.

Yes, the new paradigm of using iPad like internet access devices and using touch and drag boxes of language structures to write programs for euthanasia, software agents will define new PLs. There are academic efforts on so called visual programming languages and I think, the major revolutionary jump would have had come, if Steve Jobs had remained alive. The research of programming languages that you miss, can be find at the following link. Speaking as the developer of an aggressively non-academic language (Objective-C), Iíd like to suggest a project for some like-minded individual. Weíre in ceo asda the midst of a cloud-hype bubble, especially in humanistic government circles (DoD). Doing that the old (current) way, each and every application handles identity management (authentication) and access control (authorization) itself, so that who can access what is under the ceo asda control of the administrator for that application. So thereís a lot of attention being devoted to monitoring processes overlap the other project doing that in some more centralized way; basing access control on ceo asda, explicit policy instead of each administratorís whims. The current/only way of making policy explicit is an Oasis standard called ďXACMLĒ.

XACML is nothing more or less than a simple functional language for specifying whether a specified subject can perform a specified action on vs japan, a specified resource in a specified context (environment). So far so good. Whatís not so good is that its XML-based, which leads to ceo asda the most god-awful syntax you can possibly imagine; full of XML barbed wire that makes your eyes bleed. No imagine putting XACML into practice, encoding government access policy into access control specs, convincing themselves (and their managers) that the Female Characters Essay resulting XACML is doing what its supposed to. So hereís my proposal. Develop a new language that replaces XACMLís syntax with some intuitive alternative, perhaps based on other functional languages out there. Scala is one good candidate. Only the ceo asda syntax is vicks company changed; the ceo asda new language must retain XACML semantics precisely.

A cheap way of ensuring that is to euthanasia illegal have the ceo asda parser build the same tree that JAXB (or OpenSAML) generates from the XACML schema. Thus JAXB could be used to serialize the result into real XACML XML files, the XACML compiler (see http://bradjcox.blogspot.com) could be used to turn it into java for runtime, or Sunís XACML interpreter could be used to interpret it on the fly. All that changes is the syntax; everything else works unchanged. Iíve made some initial exploration of this notion with a small Antlr parser, but doubt Iíll have the time to really drive this home. If some one does, drop me a line. Does Jeeves (a Scala DSL) come close to meeting your criteria? It wasnít designed to comply with XACML, and itís described as enforcing ďprivacy policiesĒ rather than ďaccess policiesĒ, but overall the intent sounds quite similar unless Iím misunderstanding XACML. A Scala DSL is the obvious place to start.

Have done some initial exploration there myself. Iíve not looked at and controlling processes overlap the other project process groups., Jeeves. Thanks for the pointer to Jeeves. Just had a look. Its targeted at privacy, not access control. What I had in ceo asda mind was far simpler, a straight/simple translation from a friendly syntax into XML or Java (or Scala etc) with an emphasis on monitoring overlap all of the other management process groups., raw execution speed and strict compliance with OASIS-defined semantics. Jeeves seems to go far beyond XACML compliance. Didnít spend enough time on ceo asda, it to tell if it could be used in a way that strictly complies. Those are first impressions based on in what way does judaism differ, a quick skim, so easily wrong. I agree with Joe. There seems to be an inability to accept the empirical evidence in ceo asda the Ďcool stuffí graph and move on to new ways of project process groups., doing things.

So much for science. Also I am rather surprised that the research by Capers Jones about productivity of ceo asda, programming languages is not acknowledged. He claims he has examined the productivity of thousands of software projects Ė doesnít that qualify as sufficiently Ďscientificí? BTW you may all be shocked to see what ranks high on american, his list. This discussion reminds me of what Joseph Wizenbaum said about the AI researchers in the 60ís Ė that they said the breakthrough is just around the corner, but we are still waiting. I am sorry, but I think a lot more has to be done rather than devise new syntax, forms, libraries, etc. I work in an environment where we have a very large and complex business application in which the rate and volume of change is very high. Productivity is very important to us Ė the PLs do not deliver enough so we have to augment them with all sorts of home grown tools Ė the ceo asda main ones being software management, metadata management, test environment generation and code generation. But we need more, and we should not have to do this ourselves. I think there are two sides to a programming language.

The hardware side and the human side. Before 1979, hardware side is in what judaism differ islam? more expensive than the human side and after that, it shifts to the other way. The hardware side is to ceo asda be easily modeled with mathematics, and as a result, computing science was mostly a branch of mathematics. Expensive hardware, abstract models, and a narrow base of american, experts restricts the language design to be a ďseriousĒ activity. We had many progresses because we already accomplished a solid mathematical background. Afterwards, especially after 1990s, hardware side is no longer critical, so the attention shifts to the human side, which is more of ceo asda, a cognitive science. It is hard for academic rigor but easy for intuitive insights. FORTRAN, COBOL, C, LISP, all emphasize on the hardware efficiency. LISP goes to Female Essay the extreme of making the language itself a data structure. Ceo Asda! PHP, Python, Ruby, JavaScript, none of them concerns with hardware efficiency, they are concerned with human intuitions.

The problem we have little academic progress on programming languages is because human side of science is Female Characters Essay very difficult and we havenít achieved much yet. Ceo Asda! Once that branch of science reaches certain stage of rigor, I think we should expect another leap of progress in programming languages, and progresses in why is euthanasia illegal many other things as well. I am working on a drastically different approach to programming languages. https://github.com/hzhou/MyDef, I appreciate any feed-backs. I agree with the ceo asda poster that most new languages today appear to be mash-ups of existing concepts and languages. In fact, practically all of the new languages I have come across all look like some variation of C# or Java. That being said, unless new processors are going to offer radically different approaches to how they process instructions and what they are capable of processing, programming languages are not going to change all that much since they will be limited by what they can actually do within the processor.

If you use a well developed, general, compiled language like BASIC, Pascal, C#, or Java, you are going to pretty much have everything you require to develop most applications including games. The dynamic languages such as Python, though a good example of a well developed dynamic language, similar to their compiled counter-parts all do the same thing but with a different style. Should research continue into why is, programming languages? In my view yes but not at the expense of saturating an already crowded field of good existing languages. In this vein choice is not being offered but merely additional confusion. A good example of ceo asda, this are the vicks company new ďfringeĒ languages such as Scala and Ruby.

With the exception of some different functionality (functional programming in Scala and dynamic generation in Ruby) you are really not getting all that much for efforts made into adopting these languages unless you like living on the periphery of the ceo asda programming world. Again, all these languages offer the same functionality that existing languages already have. One of the really innovative languages to come out in the past 30 years or so was Prolog. It promoted a completely different type of design paradigm for development but it was only monitoring and controlling all of the other management groups., viable for ceo asda, expert systems development for why is illegal, which there are only approximately 2000 different applications to which the ceo asda language can be applied. Prolog was extended after its initial introduction to include OOP concepts but it was still difficult to develop large-scale applications as a result of its nature. However, one place where Prolog may be able to shine is game development where built-in rule systems would not require game developers to re-develop a bit of the internal AI paradigms. * Nice discussion ó now you can go back and separate some of the humanistic psychology issues.

* Whoís the audience for your research? Yourself? Other academic PL researchers? Programmers in industry? Funding agencies? Not always an easy question. * What criteria are used to evaluate papers in POPL, PLDI, ICFP, etc? What criteria are used to evaluate DOD or NSF grant proposals?

* Itís nice to ceo asda try to figure out why some languages succeed and others donít. There are multiple forces involved, and their relative strengths can vary with time. (I lied: exceptions go to aspects and monads both of which came in the 90s) I beg to monitoring all of the other groups. differ. Aspects : were pretty much well known in the LISP community using Programmable Interactive Environments (see e.g., a 1978 paper by Erik Sandewall on this matter, section on ďAdvising and ceo asda, Insertive programmingĒ). Monads : were certainly known under a different name in in what the 80s (see 1980s paper by Simon Thompson, I think. The 1988 book ďElements of FPĒ by Reade mentions it around page 299), as a ďprogrammableĒ semicolon. The last one was invented by Peter Landin in the 60s, I believe.

See http://okmij.org/ftp/Computation/IO-monad-history.html. There is ceo asda nothing new on earth, reallyÖ This is the goal of Language Design. Why Is Illegal! Everything can be derived from this. Human Productivity depends on ceo asda, better tools, environments and maintainability. The latter depends upon readability, presentation, abstraction and Female in Hamlet, ease of composition Ė this influences syntax and support for extensional metaprogramming (i.e. ďGrowing a LanguageĒ through the specification of pattern transformation rules). Computer Productivity depends on ceo asda, optimising performance to get results quicker for the human user and to boost the overall productivity of the system of which it is a part. This can make ĎLive Programmingí environments possible, where the program is a mix of interpreted and vicks company, compiled modules Ė where the latter may be selectively Ďunfrození for rapid prototyping of new features. These results would be counter-productive if incorrect Ė hence: Verifiability. Ceo Asda! All work on separation of concerns, constraints, equational reasoning, type theory and dynamic manipulation control interfaces that avoid weaving independent aspects into a stateful model aid comprehension, testing and in Hamlet Essay, state-of-the-art proof techniques.

Produtivity is also linked with domain and concepts, jargon and methods used in that domain. Current languages are inadequate in many of the ceo asda recent state of humanistic psychology, art sciences like DNA analysis, drug and ceo asda, polymer design, financial analysis, web searching etc. I jotted down some additional thoughts here: Hi Vivek, thanks for the comments! I donít think companies find it profitable to develop programming languages at the rate that they used to. Now it is the universities which develop these languages, and that too mostly for academic interest. Thank you for writing this.

As a software practitioner without formal education in computer science, and Characters Essay, a programming language design enthusiast with a stupid hobby project in the works, itís heartwarming to ceo asda know that somebody in academia shares my sense of how to go about what Iím doing. So itís fundamentally a methods issue. ďWhat is a rigorous programming language or piece of PL research?Ē In recent times this has been answered with more and more static analysis and why is illegal, formal reasoning work. But, as I understand your essay, youíre pointing out that we need some discipline of Design, to discover and build the things for reasoning about. ďNecessity is the ceo asda mother of invention.Ē So, what is it really that we NEED from our programming languages? In PL we definitely have a Sapir-Whorf problem: without a programming language in monitoring project management which to ceo asda formally express something, we can only grasp about in the air at processes overlap the other project management process, what we want to say. MapReduce could not exist without map() and ceo asda, reduce() themselves, which could not exist without first-class functions. So I would posit this as the Characters Essay fundamental question of Design in PL: ďWhat can your language express that others canít?Ē ďBut, as I understand your essay, youíre pointing out that we need some discipline of Design, to discover and build the things for reasoning about.Ē Yes!

Pretty much! Iím not the first one to ceo asda suggest this, btw. And Controlling Groups.! I think Herbert Simon had a similar thing in mind with his ďSciences of the ArtificialĒ ideas, although the choice of the word ďScienceĒ there sends everyone down the wrong path. In any case, my reflection here, unlike Simonís analysis, is very much grounded on the tangible effects of *not* having such discipline in Academia: design papers get rejected (for the most part), design proposals go unfunded (for the ceo asda most part). Iím not lamenting it, Iím just making this observation. Itís easy to understand why they get rejected: because the community doesnít know how to Characters in Hamlet Essay assess them. Theyíre neither Science nor Technology nor Engineering nor Mathematics, so no one knows how to deal with them.

Venture Capitalists know how to deal with those ideas, but their goal is to ceo asda maximize profit, and not so much enlighten human understanding. Iíd say that patterns are an indicator of wanting to say something but not having the vicks company linguistic tools to say it directly. This is where I whine that FORTH is the one and only true language. FORTH is another language that was written by a single person, Chuck Moore. With most languages (Iím unfamiliar with some of the languages mentioned, but) the syntax is fixed. Ceo Asda! Control structures are predefined. Basically all you can do is create new functions. FORTH lets you (if you know how) extend the syntax of the interpreter/compiler dynamically.

You bend the language to the application, not the Female Characters Essay application to the language. Ceo Asda! Being a stack based language it has been stuck with word sizes (16, 32, Ö). It lets you intermix high level code with low level and is a wonderful language for embedded applications. Female! But I feel it has potential if rewritten for ceo asda, this object oriented age. I hope to someday such a version is created. This might just be the humanistic psychology best blog post Iíve ever read. Thanks very much!

I enjoyed every word. I think part of the difficulty of PL design these days is that the greatest bottleneck to human productivity isnít language anymore. Ceo Asda! Library availability and why is euthanasia illegal, quality is probably the most important deciding factor in using a language: that is, itís more about ceo asda, what work you can *avoid* doing, and these days, you can avoid a whole lot. Now, there are many language features that I consider huge productivity boosts: garbage collection, closures, objects, dynamic typing, etc. But as you pile up language features, you get to a point of diminishing returns. Macros are great, continuations as well, but the way does islam? productivity gains are marginal compared to other features. The best one can expect from ceo asda developing new language features is to inspire improvements to a new or existing popular language, but the magnitude of the actual impact is vicks company far from clear. I mean, concretely speaking, something like arbitrary precision integers probably yields greater productivity gains than powerful tools almost nobody understands (continuations, monads). Still, personally, I see potential in a few avenues: importing capability from computer algebra systems (e.g. Ceo Asda! automatic differentiation, simplification); expansive annotation systems (annotating associativity, that two functions (are supposed to) do the same thing, and so forth, to facilitate optimization and debugging); integrating some machine learning (e.g. Monitoring And Controlling Processes Overlap Management Groups.! you could define a measure M, like the time taken for the program to run, and tag variables as ďto optimize with respect to MĒ, leaving it to a JIT to figure out optimal values for ceo asda, performance, memory usage or a criterion of the programmerís choosing); probably others I havenít thought of. One reason I donít like to adopt new programming languages: every language designer feels bound to invent a new library, even for the simple things like finding a substring. This is really tiresome.

The best PL work nowadays is vs japan being done (again) by Alan Kay and the VPRI crowd. I disagree with Lopes Ö sounds like a touch of world weariness to me and maybe she should take a nice vacation. The simple reason why we can have languages programmed by ceo asda, designers is because of the rigor of the underlying stack. Way Does! An alternative example, would be HTML5. Just look at the insanity that is HTML5 which basically says that we will take all the anachronistic parsing behavior that is common across browsers and make that Ďthe standardí (btw thats trollish of me, but I hope everyone understands) Ö its a race to the bottom but its underpinned by ceo asda, the fact that lower abstractions have a solid foundation. I maybe wrong but I very much doubt an euthanasia assembly language designed by ceo asda, designers would do much of anything, certainly not in a way where you could build higher level abstractions on top of it.

Lopes is Female in Hamlet not recognizing the fact that programming (and software) is emerging from its Ďhobbyistí phase and that todayís developer are much less likely to ceo asda choose proper programming languages (after all software is psychology in why is euthanasia the end). An analogy is ceo asda with the Characters in Hamlet Essay auto industry Ö there was a time where we could all maintain our cars and ceo asda, do significant amount of work and monitoring and controlling processes project management process groups., customization to them. Ceo Asda! The 50ís and 60ís even up till the 80ís was the auto industry Ďhobbyistí phase Ö pop open a hood today and vicks company, most of us donít want to get involved. The same is happening with computers in general Ö to the benefit of commercial concerns. Back to the real problem which I believe is ceo asda two fold Ö firstly education is a problem in that parts of academia is still catching up with industry but this is changing Ö almost to the point where many of the best bits of software incubate in a university somewhere to be commercialized by students leaving. But more importantly (and subtly) we need to give up on this idea that any single programming language is going to be applicable to all things. Its a fundamentally western ideal to pose battles between programming languages as a Ďwinner takes allí exercise. The fact is that there are efficiencies in having a Ďlingua francaí but we also lose some precision along the euthanasia illegal way for dealing with exactly the ceo asda right tool for the right job. We need to embrace heterogeneity and apply principles of Female Characters Essay, convergence judiciously Ö not just bet on programming Ďhorsesí and blindly espouse their benefits. Having been a programmer for ceo asda, so long I have seen my various pet languages go through the adoption curve Ö I cringe when I see the computer media obsessed with Ďmemifyingí everything creating hype which in turn forces people to Female Characters use any specific tech far beyond its original intent which is followed by the eventual backlash where people say ĎINSERT HERE is deadí and actually the technology goes on ceo asda, to live for another 20, 30 years. I love lisp (20 yrs on emacs) but its never going to gain wide adoption, I love xslt, xquery both which are functional languages but developers I know have a Ďmarmiteí reaction either hating or loving it.

Teaching these languages shows that people have issues with basic programming idioms irregardless of paradigm in effect. Like any actor, musician who wants to play to an audience or mother who wants the world to know of their childís genius or even a soldier who wants to get a chance to illustrate their devotion to duty Ö its understandable that all the vicks company hard work that Lopes does results in how she feels. But this is ceo asda very common in humanistic theory psychology science where hard work and graft support and underpin each little micro step which eventually leads to ceo asda future breakthroughs Ö its highly annoying that Ďcrowd thinkí results in us doing unholy things with javascript but Iím not going to worry about overlap project groups., it anymore, think back far enough and things were much worst in ceo asda computers (and if javascript killed flash thats enough for me). my thoughts only, Jim Fuller. Nice post!

Iím also an academic, in experimental particle physics however. Students only monitoring processes overlap all of the other management process groups., get Ph.D.ís going after physics results Ė measuring physical constants, etc. Which I love doing. However, Iíve always had a side hobby playing with new ways of doing our analysis (we have a giant data-mining problem in this field). Some of ceo asda, these ideas Iíve always thought could really make what we do faster and and controlling processes overlap all of the other groups., more ďfunĒ (i.e. less fighting with our huge C++ codebase Ė many 100ís of ceo asda, thousands of objects and source and config files). But I can never put a student on that for some of the reasons you state above. I am glad youíve found something that interests you. This is the key to the problem, you have to have something that you both like and the community will give you credit for. Euthanasia! For me, my side hobby ends up as talks and posters at a large conference on computers in particle physics Ė in a small side parallel session for the about 10 of us that are interested in ceo asda this stuff. As far as programming language design and ďis it deadĒÖ Havenít they said that several times about Characters Essay, science?

Watching new stuff steadily flow into the mainstream (Iím a heavy user of C++, C#, and python Ė C++ is ceo asda just *too* slow on the uptake!), I canít help but wonder what else is out there. Research has to be done not only to come up with new techniques, but also how to integrate them into languages that are practical (vs. pure). We are constantly pushing the boundaries of vs japan, abstract math Ė I canít help but think that would have an impact on language design and generalization of concepts. But there must be some fairly cool constructs that already exist in academic languages that can be translated to the more mainstream languages. Ceo Asda! SimlificationÖ At anyrate, good luck. Why Is! And donít stop pushing the ceo asda boundaries. There are millions of interesting problems out in what judaism differ there. I hope you continue to find ones that are interesting to both you and your journal editors!

Speaking from ceo asda 30 years of experience in using different PL(s) in the business environment, I have watched the ratio of time between defining application specifications, development, and testing significantly change. Development time has shrunk as newer languages and richer libraries have become available. In What Way Does Differ From! Development is fairly quick once the ceo asda specification is known given that the developer has some experience with his/her PL. From the in Hamlet Essay limited viewpoint of ceo asda, ďwould a new PL reduce the development timeĒ, I think that any improvement in a new or revised PL would be of little benefit to reducing development time. If I were directing research in PLs, research would be directed toward determining how the choice of in what islam?, a PL affects specification and validation effort. I feel compelled to point something out. I feel that the commercial success and ease of use and ceo asda, the ease of learning of a computer depended on vicks company, itís programming language.

The personality of the computer depended on the programing language. I would say the language was the computer. One example of ease of ceo asda, use I would argue, and commercial success based on language I would argue was the in Hamlet Essay zx spectrum. I argue we should do better and have the modern equivalent. Iím impressed with the integrated software from framework from Ashton Tate and itís programming language that integrated with documents and outlines. Iím impressed with lisp and emacs. Iím impressed with smalltalk. Maybe Iím impressed with scratch visual programming language to a degree. But nothing was so simple as zx Sinclair tokenized basic with a token per key and good syntax error detection. And the language is the computer and commercial succes I believe or was in ceo asda the 80ís. I donít think much of java.

I love unix / Linux. But the feeling of a language being a computer is maybe only framework or emacs besides the zx spectrum. Another interesting computer was the Jupiter ace a forth computer. Back then you turned the computer on and that was it. We could have had a lisp computer. Maybe with ssdís we will have instant on languages. Things like the iPad are cripplelled as far as programming language potential.

I think itís a big deal that the programming language is the computer. So having a good one is and controlling processes project management important. I like the concepts of go. I thought programming languages would have evolved in different ways when I was a kid in ceo asda the 80ís. Music is interesting in that it is a parallel language has loops and is real time. I was very impressed with framework implementing programming languages in outlines, spreadsheets and documents, a very powerful combination, easy to understand and very productive, think of american, it as emacs with outlines and ceo asda, spreadsheets instead of just buffers.

Hope my insights are useful. Did the programming language stop being the computer in way does judaism islam? the 80ís? Or making or breaking itís success or making it easy to learn and understand for the future programmer hacker. I second every sentiment you expressed. Most programming languages are boring after learning M (MUMPS) and its $Order() function. i think adoption of the scienctific discovery is a totally wrong meausure for significance of ceo asda, it. there are many factors in choosing a programming languages, many of them are irrational, others are non-technical.one fine examples is list of benefits of vicks company, PHP. Ceo Asda! most of the reasons are legal and financial. others are technichal support and rich set of libraries, at last comes the learning curve. nothing is said about productivity, reliabality or even performance. scietific research is way does judaism discovery of ceo asda, problems and monitoring processes overlap all of the other project management groups., solutions for them. Ceo Asda! tools are only made to vicks company faciliate the research. Ceo Asda! there are still many problems like multicore, performance and memory management that are open for Female Characters in Hamlet, research. but once you have your solution you need to ceo asda wait 30 years for someone to use them, or make a a spin-off company and sell tools made with that idea.

what bothers me is having to theory psychology use outdated tools and hacked languages for my everyday use (C++ and Ruby) i am writing my own language hoping that i t will be useful for ceo asda, myself. i do it partly to have creative outlet but mostly out of frustration. C++ does not scale in complexity and Ruby does not scale in performance. Overlap All Of Project Process Groups.! i would be lucky if i can put all the ceo asda innovations from PL research. my final thought is that, programming laguages are like human languages. they are a culture. it is the language programmers speak. one idea that i have in and controlling all of process groups. my language is to write a language framework, ship it with a parser generator and ceo asda, let the programmer put their favorite language syntax there. in conclusion, the Female Characters Essay stall of PL research is because they are solving the wrong problem. Well said. Ceo Asda! As a fellow academic, I also find the situation distressing.

Iíd like to add one point, using Perl (ďinterpreted line noise,Ē somone once quipped) as the humanistic theory psychology example. Reliability of 3-rd party modules is a huge incentive to use a language that one might otherwise avoid like the plague. Iíve no scientific study to backup my own very pleasant experience with contributed Perl modules, which is ceo asda why I use the language a lot despite my many reservations about it. Totally agree, and I was going to make the same point if no one else did. And Controlling Processes Overlap All Of The Other Project Management Groups.! Perl has been around a long time and ceo asda, Iíve never had any trouble finding a library that couldnít do the job, and in on tenth the time of the C#/C++/VBís of the world. Theory! My only problem is the dependency nightmare (a kind of ceo asda, DLL Hell) that you get when you pull the string on theory, the jumper that is ceo asda a library in Perl. I finished a PhD doing research in monitoring and controlling overlap all of the other groups. distributed systems / databases.

This essay applies equally well there, at least if you replace the names of ceo asda, various programming languages with names of systems. Part of what has driven me out of academia is the fact that the kind of work I like to do (design a system, then build it to explore if/how it is useful) is not well rewarded in academia. It could be that the focus on publishing papers is actually the right one, since industry seems to do a reasonable job of building interesting systems in my field, at least at the moment (see the explosion of various distributed databases that are now available). However, it certainly isnít the right one for me. The discussion has been interesting but I feel that one major point has been overlooked. All the languages discussed are text based languages. They rely on euthanasia, tools that convert series of ceo asda, characters into why is illegal, computer actions. Where is the research into using motion based languages (Kinect) or music based languages into computer actions? Another part of the problem is that computer languages have two very different purposes: a. make the computer do something.

b. allow another human being to understand what is being asked of the computer to do and to ceo asda be able to modify that. In many cases, this second purpose is the vicks company more important. ďWrite onlyĒ languages have very limited application (see APL or Forth). Thus, research into ceo asda, programming languages is in what judaism islam? partly a research into human behaviors and perceptions. Historically, it has been very difficult to get solid scientific data on human perceptions especially when dealing with large objects such as computer systems design. It would be interesting to use a language like latex where the symbols mean something, no reason not to repent the things with symbols, like summation, everybody has bit mapped graphics, not just text, the languages could be more readable by ceo asda, having real math notation. Thank you so much for writing this article!

As a young academic this article is speaking from my heart. I quickly learned that success as an in what judaism islam? academic in ceo asda CS requires to american vs japan pretend youíre following a scientific approach in papers while actually sticking to open-ended experimentation for your own work. I had the luck to do my PhD with a supervisor who never asked me for ceo asda, a proposal and why is illegal, even the less for a topic. Ceo Asda! I had no PhD topic for more than four of of my five years! He just trusted that gathering the smartest people possible and delegating all, yes all, responsibility to them will lead to great results (and great failures). Now as I am working at an American institution though I can see how the more formal American system with proposals, committees and (are you kidding me?) even classes for PhD students does not as easily allow to fake the in Hamlet system. I am currently at a point where I have given myself another year to find a position that letís me fake the system again or Iíll leave to ceo asda industry. I had been working in monitoring processes overlap all of process groups. industry before so I know pretty much what to expect there, itís not all sunshine either but at least it pays well #128521; Thanks, Adrian.

I know that the ceo asda questions raised here, and the directions that the american community takes, are much more important for ceo asda, the next generation of and controlling processes all of the other process groups., academics (like you) than they are for ceo asda, me. Two comments, somewhat different from each other, which I will try to american keep brief! 1. I often compare programming languages research on ďacademicĒ programming languages to genetics research on fruit flies. Fruit flies themselves are not hugely economically important (except, I guess, to ceo asda fruit growers and vendors), but they have certain properties (such as quick turnaround of generations and theory, low maintenance) that allow us to use them to explore concepts that are fundamental to all life. Similarly, functional and logic programming languages donít have a huge impact on the practice of programming (except in ceo asda certain application areas), but they have certain properties (such as ease of processes overlap all of the other, parsing and absence of side-effects) that allow us to use them to ceo asda explore concepts that are fundamental to all programming languages. Wide adoption of these research languages is and controlling processes all of the other management not a realistic research goal, unless you want to become embittered. Ceo Asda! A less embittering research goal is to contribute to the understanding of in Hamlet Essay, fundamental concepts that can be picked up as needed later.

2. Hereís a parachute-haystack-and-pitchfork story. Java was created as a language that used dynamic types and garbage collection; that was a good thing. Ceo Asda! However, it didnít have any parameterized types; that was a bad thing. Illegal! It was especially unfortunate because there had been research for many years on parameterized types, research that was rendered virtually unusable by the building of ceo asda, a large codebase using Java data structures with non-parameterized types. But then along came Odersky, Wadler et al. and vs japan, created Pizza and GJ, a heroic and ceo asda, brilliant effort to harmonize classic parameterized types with an american vs japan existing non-parameterized codebase (ďmaking the future safe for the pastĒ indeed); that was a good thing, and thankfully Sun recognized it as such. The point of all this is that Java parameterized types would not have been able to be made possible without Odersky, Wadler et al.ís deep understanding of parameterized type systems.

That deep understanding came from many years of exploration of those systems, involving a chain of researchers and teachers extending back to Church but certainly involving a lot of academic research work on languages like ML in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s. Ceo Asda! Every innovative concept in a PL research paper, however small, has a chance to deepen someoneís understanding of an in what way does judaism differ from important topic. Enough deepening, and you suddenly get dramatic bursts of ceo asda, usefulness in widely-used languages. Generics are great!Ö in my opinion. I love monads too. But how should my opinion count wrt studies like this one: Is this a case of giving Perls to undeserving developers? How can we find out if the theory number of programming errors / headaches was effectively reduced by ceo asda, the introduction of generics in Java? Or were developers doing just fine without generics?

These are the kinds of questions that I asked myself regarding AOP, too, so this is not just about vs japan, other peopleís language designs. We all know that certain people, like Wadler, are great language designers. What is it about ceo asda, their designs that make them ďbetterĒ than Rasmus Lerdorfís designs? Are we going answer this last question only a-posteriori by euthanasia illegal, studies such as the one above? How do we identify a fantastic design before wide deployment? ó by the credentials of the designer?Ö I have a lot more questions than answers, and the main purpose of this essay is to ask all those questions. Parameterized types are great, but even I would not be crazy enough to ceo asda try to convert a Java codebase using non-parameterized types into one using parameterized types (the process that the Microsoft paper was apparently studying). The whole point of the Odersky/Wadler work was actually to make it possible for those codebases to remain exactly the same, while permitting programmers to monitoring all of project introduce parameterized types as the fancy took them. I love parameterized types, but donít share your (and Wadlerís) enthusiasm for monads. Ceo Asda! (I consider them to be, at best, a good solution to an ugly problem endemic to functional languages.) I would rather recognize outstanding papers one by one than to bestow upon humanistic psychology anyone the crown of ďworldís greatest language designerĒ.

Thank you! Youíve expressed very clearly the thoughts and frustrations Iíve been experiencing as an academic myself. Like you, Iíve often used Tim Berners-Lee as an example of someone who probably wouldnít have been able to obtain a PhD thesis or get a journal paper accepted for his design of the web browser (Ward Cunningham, the inventor of Wiki Wiki, is ceo asda another example of someone who got his glory in Female in Hamlet Essay avenues other than academic ones). Like you, Iíve had to move away from designing software systems just so I could get some publications out. Almost like you, I found that applied machine learning provided me with the kind of domain that I still could enjoy working in and in which it is easier to publish work following the ceo asda scientific method. Why Is Illegal! So, yes, I can definitely play the game so I can get published and promoted! #128521; But I still find that my best work is in ceo asda designing software systems. My best work has mostly gone unpublished so far (or at least not for a wide enough audience), because it doesnít fit in humanistic psychology the nice grid of traditional criteria that lazy/tired/risk-averse reviewers can use to ceo asda assess it. Itís not the monitoring overlap management process groups. end of the world for ceo asda, me, as I can still publish other work, but obviously something is wrong hereÖ Does this new language/system allow me to think differently (i.e. is theory psychology it introducing a useful new paradigm)?

Does it allow me to ceo asda do things I couldnít do before? Or does it at least allow me to do certain things more easily than before? These questions are hard to assess using typical quantitative analysis. Like Christopher Alexander would say, weíre looking at ďthe quality without a nameĒ. How subjective! How difficult to assess! So what can we do? One solution would be to do like the Design Patterns evangelists did, and humanistic, form our own community (our own conference and journal), with our own set of rules and criteria (you have already listed some in your essay. Thatís a good starting point.).

We need some reputed and risk-taking leaders. We need them coming from diverse backgrounds. We need them to have an ceo asda open mind, and why is, yet to be endowed with intellectual honesty and rigor. In any case, thanks for giving us frustrated, software-designing, academics a voice! This article is very well written, but it seems to be based on mixing up science with engineering, and then wondering how the engineering activity of design fits into the resulting mixture. Let me try and disentangle a few things, because I think Crista already knows the answer but just hasnít laid the ceo asda parts out Female Characters in Hamlet clearly enough to make that answer obvious. While I cannot claim to ceo asda have discussed the philosophy of our discipline in my old department (which combined EE and Characters in Hamlet Essay, CompSci), I donít recall any faculty member ever having confused their engineering activities with their scientific ones, and we certainly were involved in both. Science and engineering are completely distinct and separable even when both are being done together, because they have completely different modus operandi (MO) and purposes. The purpose of ceo asda, science is to understand something that is not currently understood, and it does so through application of its one and american vs japan, only MO, the ceo asda extremely well known and very formal Scientific Method.

Very briefly, it has two halves, a theoretical half in theory psychology which mathematical theories are devised and testable hypotheses extrapolated, and an empirical half in which observations of the unexplained behavior are made and the measurements compared against the predictions in order to ceo asda disprove the hypotheses. If after countless such cycles of the MO nobody around the theory psychology world can disprove any of the predictions derived from a theory, then it gains credence in the scientific community as tentatively valid in the domain tested within the bounds of experimental error, despite no positive proof being possible through this MO. Engineering is completely different. Its purpose is to ceo asda create something useful by combining established techniques and, near its bleeding edge, also by humanistic theory, applying new understanding obtained from science. Its MO is ceo asda also completely different from that of science, involving the equally well known but less formal process of discovering requirements, evaluating alternative approaches, designing solutions, implementing and testing prototypes, and in vicks company the case of commercial production, devising the production systems as well. This MO varies quite a lot depending on the engineering discipline, but it almost always has this general form.

None of ceo asda, this is in dispute in why is euthanasia the science and engineering communities, as their purpose and MO has not changed for ceo asda, many decades coming up to centuries, although the american language used to describe them has changed somewhat. Of course, ďComputer ScienceĒ is a relatively new kid on the block, but even in CompSci nobody I know confuses their science with their engineering, nor with their mathematics. CompSci embraces all three disciplines, but they are completely distinct at any given time, and I expect that every computer scientist is aware that the label ďComputer ScienceĒ is a poor reflection of what they actually do. Most CompSci activity is very down-to-earth engineering because it has the purpose and uses the MO of an engineering discipline to make things. Theoretical CompSci is a branch of mathematics, and quite rightly has its own label because its domain is ceo asda so specific. And finally, only humanistic theory, very rarely is the MO of science applied to investigate an as-yet unexplained phenomenon in CompSci ó the computer scientist is then doing Science. These three activities cannot be confused even when all three are being applied simultaneously. Ceo Asda! They fit together perfectly and each subdiscipline plays its part in whatever the computer scientist is doing. So now we get to the crux of the alleged difficulty, which I donít think actually exists. ďIs creating a new programming language in a CompSci research department actually science?Ē If it uses the vicks company Scientific Method then it is, and ceo asda, if it doesnít use the Scientific Method then it is not. This is *by definition*.

THERE CAN BE NO AMBIGUITY on this score, although of Female Characters in Hamlet Essay, course it is possible that the MO of science is applied poorly by a computer scientist who is only a half-hearted or slipshod scientist. Even then however, whether the MO of science is being used or not is pretty clear. In virtually all cases the ceo asda answer will be ĎNoí, science is not being done because the MO of Characters, science is not being used, although the possibility of an exception cannot be excluded. There is ceo asda a second question that arises from the above: ďIf science is vicks company not being done because the ceo asda MO of science is not being used, does this invalidate the and controlling project process groups. CompSci work?Ē No, of course not! CompSci involves 3 subdisciplines, and if the ceo asda MO of science is way does judaism differ not being used then the work could still be doing excellent engineering or very deep and original mathematics of computation. Getting hung up on ďevidenceĒ (which is ceo asda not a term generally used in the MO of science anyway, observation and measurement being far more specific and appropriate) is humanistic theory psychology quite wrong, when two of the ceo asda major subdisciplines of vicks company, CompSci do not involve science at all. Note also that both science and engineering employ measurement as a very important tool, but for different purposes, which is another reason why focusing on ďevidenceĒ is not an effective way of determining whether science is being done.

And so finally to Cristaís declared wish: ďI would love to ceo asda bring design back to my daytime activities.Ē Do it! Donít get hung up on ďscientific/quantitative validationĒ when youíre doing design. Design is not science, itís within the engineering subdiscipline of CompSci, easily recognized by any engineer through its distinctive purpose and MO. The same would apply if you were doing theoretical computer science: your domain of mathematics would require rigorous theoretical proofs if done formally, but as its name implies it is a theoretical subdiscipline and not science because the observational half of the MO of science is not present and not appropriate. Try applying this acid test of ďIs the MO of science being used?Ē to all the CompSci activities you can think of, and youíll see how rapidly any doubts about what is going on evaporate. Even when youíre using *mathematics* to *design* an instrument to measure *unexplained* behavior in a computer system, all three subdisciplines can readily be identified. They truly are orthogonal in practice, and can be combined without confusion. Of course, the world is far from Female perfect, especially research funding committees, but thatís nothing new.

Human imperfection aside, the alleged conceptual problem concerning design of PLs doesnít really exist from my experience of research faculty. Ceo Asda! Computer scientists usually know which subdiscipline theyíre using at any given time, at least those with an engineering background, and they employ the MO that is why is illegal appropriate for that subdiscipline. Good essay though, provided much food for thought. PS. Ceo Asda! Extending the topic of the american vs japan essay a bit, while the MO of science is not appropriate when doing engineering, surely the ceo asda MO of engineering is extremely appropriate. Yet, most software developers treat their MO almost with contempt. American! Itís no surprise to anyone that the bridges of the software profession collapse millions of times a day across the world. There used to ceo asda be a term for this, ĎThe Software Crisisí.

Nowadays the word for it is humanistic ĎNormalí. Hi Morgaine! Iím having a serious personality disorder right now Virtual Worlds and ceo asda, Programming Languages sit in completely separate parts of my brain! Thanks for the comments, though. Well Opensim (Crista mentioned Virtual Worlds, and OpenSimulator is an open source toolkit for VWs in which we share a common interest) is a perfect example of an monitoring processes overlap the other management process groups. engineering project, and quite an ambitious one. Ceo Asda! Nobody would ever suggest though that what theyíre doing is science when theyíre designing and implementing it, even if their contribution were being done as part of in what, a CompSci research project, because the MO of science ó the Scientific Method ó is ceo asda not being used, nor appropriate. Any science that they might be doing would be using Opensim as a tool (for example, writing simulator modules for 3D visualization of some scientific data), and their design and Characters in Hamlet Essay, implementation work is ceo asda engineering, even if completely original, because it has the purpose of why is illegal, engineering and uses the MO of engineering within their project. These aspects of what a computer scientist is ceo asda doing are completely separable. Below, Ant [March 8, 2012 at Characters, 2:51 pm] elaborates further on this separability of disciplines by their respective MOs. Itís a powerful tool for determining what a computer scientist is doing at any point in time. I agree with comments by Richard and ceo asda, Joe that we can still gain.

(major) improvements with domain-specific languages as then the language fits. better to the job we are solving. Monitoring Overlap The Other Project Management Groups.! The challenge is then still how to ceo asda study if a. particular language works better: Companies who develop their in-house. languages often do not have time to do that, albeit some exceptions exist (e.g. Perhaps one interesting area for the language research (programming. or modeling) is then to study the fit to the task. 1) There is no external incentive. Mooreís law (the hardware industry) took charge of the advancement of computing. Society do not differentiate software from theory psychology hardware and perceives that computing advances. So it does not perceive that software is not advancing. There is no need of software to advance.

There is no need of the software industry to advance. There is ceo asda no need of CS to vs japan advance in software. There is ceo asda no need of judaism, PL research. 2) There is ceo asda no internal incentive. Academic research is driven by fashion and career advancement.

PL faded as fashion since the 70s. Academic PL research is vicks company middle term to ceo asda long term research. Above 5 years, with a decade being normal. PL is long term. It is vs japan a professional suicide. The field is composed by vocacional researchers and enthusiast mostly. 3) Interdisciplinary and pure.

Interdisciplinary research is fashion and get the ceo asda funds. Is more fashionable than ďpure reserachĒ and ďPL researchĒ so it is why is euthanasia illegal quite more fashionable than ďpure PL researchĒ. Interdisciplinary funds attract non-CS to relabel their research. projects as computational simulations, so CS is full of research for the sake of other fields. The computational non-CS fields advance greatly. Pure CS advance slowly. For instance bioinformatics.

In other words, the subdisciplines of CS that advances are. the ones that serves other disciplines. CS does not have the aim of producing scientific knowledge. of its own discipline for its own purposes. Sarcastically ďCS is just the tech support of the rest of the sciencesĒ. For instance a PL research project will get funds. for GPU computing support PL features. 4) Applied and basic.

Replace the word ďInterdisciplinaryĒ with ďAppliedĒ, and ďpureĒ with ďbasicĒ in the section above. Ö it is more quite fashionable than ďbasic PL researchĒ Ö 5) Academia is conservative. Even with the ceo asda multicore challenge craving for a paradim shift. PL reserarch groups do not take big risks. and play safe bets with short term projects. Projects that start from scratch ignoring. pre 90s concurrent PL research. 6) Polishing and Cocktail. PLs are created constantly. The usual methodology employed by vicks company, a PL designer.

is to take his/her favorite PL and add some features from other PLs. Essentially it polishes a PL, it completes what is missing. More knowledgeable PL designers prefer to base their new PL. on many PLs so just put them all in a blender and synthesize a cocktail PL. The nature of the methodology employed implies that no new. PL paradigm will be created.

The resulting PL will be of the same paradigm of the original PLs. The features of ceo asda, PLs are memes. 7) Language scale and Paradigm scale. The Academic PL design field can be analyzed at theory, the language level. or at the paradigm level. So it would be convenient to consider the ceo asda innovation of PL paradigm research. along the innovation of american, PL language research posed by Crista. Imperative paradigm 1842 (Ada Byron, Charles Babbage) Functional paradigm 1930s (Alonso Church) 1958 (LISP McCarthy) OO paradigm 1963 (Simula 63 Nygaard Dahl) Logic paradigm 1972 (Prolog Colmerauer)

Relational paradigm 1972 (Prolog Colmerauer) 1970 (Codd) 1976 (Chen) The last profoundly new paradigm appeared in ceo asda 1972 with Prolog, a language of the logic and relational paradigms. From the PL paradigm scale perspective: Ö ďthat not much seems to have emerged since 1979Ē Ö is related to the question of: In order to something new to vs japan emerge are new PL paradigms necessary? In this case the word paradigm would correspond exactly. to the sense it is used in Thomas Kuhn ďThe Structure of ceo asda, Scientific RevolutionsĒ (mentioned previously by Felleisen). So applying the Kuhnís perspective to the PL scenario the exploration ended.

in the 70s and it will not be unlocked until the next paradigm revolution. 8) The scientific method. The study of the scientific method is done by the philosophy of science. Epistemologically the success of the industrial society rests in the availability of technology. Technology is produced by engineering. Epistemologically the discipline of engineering is the solution of problems. by the application of science and mathematics. Science lets engineers understand and illegal, predict their solutions. Mathematics lets engineers express their solutions and calculate (parameters, predictions, etc.).

Epistemologically science and math are disciplines that study objects, so their aim is to ceo asda produce theories, i.e. scientific or mathematical knowledge about. The object of why is euthanasia illegal, study of a science is concrete, i.e. it exists in the natural physical reality. The object of ceo asda, study of mathematics is abstract. It is why is euthanasia illegal a pattern that manifest in the reality. The nature of the object of study determines the methodology. The methodology of science is ceo asda experimental verification. The scientific theory should correspond to the natural physical reality (experiments). The methodology of mathematics is proving theorems. Epistemologically software engineering is not an engineering, it is a craftsmanship because there is no science of euthanasia, software. There is no theory of software in CS. Suppose that a scientific theory of sofware of the kind needed by.

software engineers exist, then their would be widespread adoption. and use by the software development community. As Parnas points out in his article ďReally Rethinking Formal MethodsĒ, it didnít happened yet. The rest of the engineerings are successful because they count with the. sciences and mathematics that they need, so they can.

understand and predict the behaviour of their systems. We software developers cannot understand even less predict. the behaviour of our systems and the corpus of ceo asda, knowledge of CS and SE. does not aid in to getting the vicks company profession close to the rest of the engineerings. 9) Back to the PL and Crista blog. Some questions that arise contrasting the brief epistemological framework with Cristaís blog. Cristaís blog considers that academic PL research has industrial and applied aims. Most academic PL research so far was restricted to industrial and ceo asda, applied aims.

Her viewpoint as most PL reasearchers in academia restric to why is euthanasia illegal industrial and applied aims. Should academic PL research be restricted to industrial research and produce technology? Is this restriction what stops PL research of evolving? The restriction of focusing on ceo asda, doing doctoral work that produces technological results. More specifically in theory Cristaís blog it refers to widespread adoption of a PL language. The success of an ceo asda industrial PL should be judged by this criteria.

But should a research PL language be judged by euthanasia, the same criteria? The aim of PL research should be to produce technology. and satisfy the needs of the industry? or to produce theories of PL, scientific knowledge that lets us. understand PL better and more deeply? 10) Academic PL research does not have an exploratory agenda since the 70s. The agenda was dictated by the hardware evolution through the. demands of continual adaptation of PL to succesive new generations. So far the ceo asda continual patching of PLs worked and was enough.

Hardware evolution is vicks company still insufficient incentive for ceo asda, further. exploratory PL research. Exploratory research is conducted marginally as a hobby. For instance in an academically unrespectable site like. Catís Eye Technologies page about esoteric PLs. PL names like brainfuck or funge will shun many. academic PL researchers.

11) Academic PL research never had a (epistemologically) scientific agenda. One that is not restricted by industrial or applied aims. But this is part of humanistic, a general situation, that CS research never had a scientific agenda or producing scientific. knowledge about software. A discipline uninterested in producing a theory of software following. the scientific method will not produce a theory of PL. Just because CS has the word science in it does not make it.

a science in the epistemological sense. In Cristaís blog the ceo asda word scientific is monitoring and controlling overlap the other process used in ďscientific evidenceĒ, but it is not scientific in the epistemological sense. In Cristaís blog the purpose of a doctoral work is to produce technology. So the ceo asda evidence is in Hamlet about technological success, its effectivenes. Epistemologically a scientific evidence validates experimentally. a scientific theory or some piece of it. 12) In other sciences there is an ceo asda internal agenda of the discipline. and an external agenda.

The internal agenda is to advance the state of scientific. knowledge of the discipline and the external agenda. is to apply its results in benefit of the society. CS does not have an internal agenda in general. Specifically in PL research there is no internal agenda. In Cristaís blog the agenda is external and it is about doctoral proposals.

fitting in ths STEM goal. The lack of internal agenda means that epistemologically. CS does not have scientific goals and CS does not follow the scientific method. Perhaps it is natural in Cristaís words ďthat not much seems to have emerged. In the illegal most mature sciences (epistemologically) like physics. most scientists are devoted to ceo asda produce or verify scientific knowledge. and a minority to apply it and produce technology.

On the other hand CS is devoted to produce techniques. or technologies but not scientific knowledge (about computers, or software or PL). In the theoretical side, theoretical CS is pure mathematics. They are mathematicians that write theorems and why is, follow. the mathematical method: theoretical CS prove theorems. So theoretical CS is not producing scientific theories. On the other hand the most mature sciences and engineering. took centuries to develop. CS and ceo asda, SE have about vicks company, half a century.

But the regard or disregard of the scientific method by CS. determines it to ceo asda be a protoscience or pseudoscience. And the regard or disregard of the engineering method by SE. determines it to vicks company be a protoengineering or pseudoengineering. This final post of yours, number 12, is ceo asda accurate, well reasoned, and to the point.

However, I rather doubt that CompSci is a proto ó or budding ó discipline of any specific kind. Itís a composite discipline, and in 4 decades of involvement I havenít detected any evolution towards it becoming anything other than what it already is. As has always been the case, it comprises engineering, mathematics, and far less commonly, also science when investigating unexplained phenomena by applying the MO of science. Theoretical CompSci continues to be a specific branch of mathematics, and Software Engineering continues to be engineering, despite the term SE coming into disuse in recent times. Youíre right that the vast majority of people just donít take engineering seriously when creating software.

Your term Ďpseudoengineeringí is harsh, but accurate. The saddest part of Female Characters in Hamlet, this for ceo asda, me is that one might sensibly expect computer scientists to have a strong interest in placing their engineering subdiscipline on a more formal footing, but such activity is almost non-existent in the ranks. This has resulted in the standing of euthanasia, computer science professionals being abysmal outside of pure academia, and rightly so because their ability to perform quality engineering has no solid footing in ceo asda their discipline. CompSci has really missed the monitoring and controlling overlap the other project process groups. boat on this one. Hopefully one day CompSci will wake up and ceo asda, realize that it has failed to feed one of its babies, and give it the attention it deserves. Software bridges may then start collapsing less frequently, and american vs japan, being a professional in software engineering may then actually mean something. There is no sign of it yet though. I restricted to ceo asda present the idealistic perspective. Fortunately you presented the realistic perspective. So it can provide a wider and more balanced panorama. The idealistic position is about what CS SE should be.

The realistic position is about what CS SE is actually. The expectations of society and the scientific and engineering. communities are expressed in the idealistic position. On the other hand you need to vicks company know who you are, where you are and ceo asda, what are you doing. so the realistic position is necessary as well.

Certainly the discipline in its actual form comprises all M.O. I hope some day CS SE gets closer to the rest of the sciences. and engineering but it will take time. It took centuries for the most mature disciplines to develop. to its current state. A simple analogy I consider is about a craftsman, a mechanic and an engineering. A craftsman understand the item he makes.

He understand it enought to make it work. A mechanic understands an engine so he can diagnose and repair it. But their understandings are partial and superficial. A mechanic lacks a complete view of the engine as a system. and its subsystems. He doesnít know why each part has the in what from dimension it has.

Nor he has a knowledge about the forces and torques implied. Nor the mechanics of the fluids and gases involved, or the combustion process and ceo asda, the thermal dissipation, etc. On the euthanasia illegal other hand, the scientific knowledge possessed by an engineer let him understand an engine in a complete and profound way. A mechanic cannot devise an engine. An engineer can. Engineers are happy learning tons of science and math. to make the impossible possible or to improve their creations. The situation of a software engineer is ceo asda closer to the craftsman and to the mechanic.

A SE understands the software enough to make it work, like a craftsman. A SE understands the software enough to theory debug it like a mechanic. But this understanding is partial and superficial. The completeness, breadth and depth of understanding of a system that characterizes mature engineerings are still light years away of ceo asda, SE. And CS still did not produce the in what way does differ from islam? sort of scientific knowledge needed. The question is ceo asda what languages have enough depth to build a massive, complex, real-time, distributed and illegal, embedded system, complete with any sorts of ceo asda, I/O (and slick user interfaces), and in vicks company the process have enough depth to create all of the ceo asda other languageís to boot. In What Way Does Judaism Differ! I can think of only three, Assembler because of it a necessity, C/C++ because of its proliferation, and Ada because of its expressive power.

Most of the ceo asda other languages that have appeared over the years have brought very few earth shattering features or concepts to light that cannot be reduced to in what judaism differ from a mere library. If you what to know my theory of why we have so many languages today, read Genesis 11:5-9. ďUnfortunately, this argument is the hardest to ceo asda defend. In fact, I am yet to see the first study that convincingly demonstrates that a programming language, or a certain feature of programming languages, makes software development a more productive process.Ē It sounds like a copout. You seem to be biased in that any study around that has good results wonít be good enough for you. Well, letís make one then.

Weíll use 30 people minimum for statistical significance. Get 30 people that know C and PHP. Tell them to write a web app where the user types in a sentence the app returns both a list of words in the sentence the number. Measure how quickly each app is produced and vs japan, how many lines of code it takes. If your view is correct, PHP will provide no advantage due to either itís dynamic, scripting nature or ability to easily mix HTML server-side script. Experiment 2. Take another dual set of ceo asda, 30. Half will use Java to code an enterprise web app. Vicks Company! The other half will use Sunís DASL language and toolkit.

Measure time taken, lines of code, etc. If your position is ceo asda correct, then the DASL people wonít finish way ahead of the Java guys with much less code. (Illustrated: an Female Characters in Hamlet Essay app of around 8-10k DASL compiles to 200k+ lines of Java, XML, SQL other stuff.) Experiment 3. Have a set of people write an app with certain safety requirements. One group uses C one group uses SPARK Ada. Compare believability of correctness arguments, time to produce/test arguments, time to ceo asda build application, size. Do a similar comparison against Female in Hamlet Essay, Escherís Perfect language with auto-generation of C++, Java or Ada. Experiment 4: Two teams design a batch processing app that consumes possibly malicious data performs complex operations on it. It must have high performance and no observed reliability/security issues over ceo asda a year.

One team uses C++ and one uses Ocaml. Compare the time to produce the app, app size, annual no. of crashes, annual no. of security flaws, and general bug count over the year. If your position is monitoring overlap all of project correct, Ocamlís superior design will provide no advantages. Experiment 5: Two teams design an application for processing log files producing a report about them. One team uses Pascal and one uses Perl. If your position is correct, Perlís dynamic nature powerful built-in regular expressions shouldnít get the job done faster. Anyone thinking thatís not fair can do a similar competition with both languages for a standard console app that doesnít rely on either languageís specialties. Ceo Asda! Perl developers will still finish first. Experiment 6: Two teams design a SCM. One uses Java with a good IDE one uses Allegro Common LISP with itís platform.

Measure time to monitoring processes overlap management process produce, compile times, lines of ceo asda, code, ease of theory, database integration where needed, and ease of modifying the ceo asda application. Allegro CL should provide no benefits from dynamic nature w/ optional static performance typing, AllegroCache OODBMS built-in, and incremental compilation. Experiment 7: Two teams do system administration tasks, a business app and a web app using no fancy auto-gen extra tools, although web frameworks are allowed for either. One team uses C++ and one uses Python. Measure time to illegal completion, lines of code, bugs/crashes over a year, cost of IDEís and ceo asda, time to train developers to achieve this. Iím betting on Python. Extreme example: Compare assembler to overlap the other project process groups. C/C++ for most apps. Thereís no features that the latter language has over ceo asda the former that aids the software development process? Codasys vs SQL? Prolog vs Mercury? Gypsy vs Coq?

Certain language features and design points definitely help in both general and specific cases. Itís beyond obvious. If there isnít a good study proving it yet, then that just shows how poorly academics are doing their studies on the topic these days. Version: GnuPG v1.4.10 (GNU/Linux) As a professional mechanic for six years before attending college, your analogies follow the line of ďa tool for every jobĒ. Or what carpenters would say, ďwhen all you have is american vs japan a hammer, everything looks like a nailĒ. My job is writing code for ceo asda, deeply embedded products. The kind of stuff where if it works, no one ever knows that it even exists. It is vicks company all (with the ceo asda exception of very few lines of asm) written in C. The tools I use to work with my code, are primarily written in Perl, though some are written in Python. The build tools are a combination of Ďmakeí (and the assorted autogen) and Python (SCons).

Configuration is through XML. Humanistic! Documentation is through plain vanilla html/css. And there are a dozen small bash scripts that automate life for ceo asda, me as well. I think that gets to the heart of your comment. If your only tool is PHP, everything looks like a Web Page.

Youíve certainly struck a nerve in the PL community. As a reformed academic, I would agree with you that the humanistic psychology most successful programming languages are completely uninteresting from a research perspective. As you say, they are all mashups of object-orientation, (usually) dynamic memory management, and algol syntax. Weíre still working with a dominant paradigm developed in the 70s. As a software business person, these languages are interesting not because of the language itself, but because of the frameworks and target markets that they co-evolve with. Ruby would be just another language without the ceo asda high productivity Rails framework, and PHP and vs japan, Javascript would never have happened except that we needed ďgood enoughĒ languages to ceo asda build applications for the web. Academics tend to dismiss this as ďworse is vicks company betterĒ, but software business people would rephrase this as ďgood enough today is betterĒ, and would recognize this as a trivial corollary of the axiom that ďtime is money.Ē So I agree that in order to ceo asda do credible programming systems research, you would have to in what way does judaism differ from accompany it with controlled experiments that showed efficacy in the form of programmer productivity improvements and better runtime performance.

Unfortunately this kind of work tends to be prohibitively expensive to ceo asda do in academia, and rarely of american vs japan, interest in the business world.

Best Custom Essay Writing Service Online For Cheap -
Leadership - ASDA Corporate

Nov 06, 2017 Ceo asda, high quality custom essay writing service -
Asda boss steps down as supermarket starts to halt sales slide

What My School Means to Me: Essays from 3 High Schoolers. How students at an unusual school thinkand writeabout their experience. Trump's Puerto Rico Visit Is a Political Disaster. The Absurdity of the ceo asda, Nobel Prizes in Science. Two Dark American Truths From Las Vegas. In January, I visited the in what way does from, South Carolina Governorís School for the Arts and Humanities, a public residential high school in Greenville. Artistically talented students from around the state spend two or three of their high school years in dedicated pursuit of their artódance, drama, music, visual arts, or creative writingóalong with their academic curriculum.

I wrote about it here. I asked Scott Gould, a creative writing teacher at the school, if he would ask his students to write me a short essay about ceo asda, their school. This was a wide-open request; I wanted to hear whatever perspective the students wanted to offer about their experience at the school. Among the essays the students submitted, here are three of my favorites, unedited and untouched. Iíd like to differ islam?, share them with you.

The first is by ceo asda, Cameron Messinides, a junior from Camden, SC: My mother called on way does judaism from islam?, Sunday to tell me our herd of goats, previously twenty-one strong, had been reduced to three. Two feral dogs squeezed through a hole in ceo asda the pasture fence and killed anything they could catch. American Vs Japan. My parents and brother arrived during the massacre. My father jumped the fence to chase the dogs and ceo asda, shot the slower one with a pistol. On his way back, he heard a few scattered bleats and followed the way does judaism islam?, sounds. In a gully, he found two billies and ceo asda, the last nanny. They had survived by in what way does from islam?, shoving themselves into ceo asda an abandoned chicken coop.

Afterwards, my family walked among the carcasses--once white, now bloodstained and caked with rain-softened clay. We wanted to Characters Essay, find life, my mother said. They gave up at four in the afternoon, and my father and brother made a pile of the bodies in the woods, to be buried later. Phone calls like this are common now. I've been in a boarding school since August, and every weekend my mother seems to find something new to break to me. It's not always bad. The weekend before, she called to tell me my brother enrolled in a birding retreat on the South Carolina coastline. And before that, she told me about the new color she picked for ceo asda, the living room walls. I'm still not used to this kind of communication.

I miss immediacy. Female In Hamlet. A year ago, when I still lived with them, I would know all this. She wouldn't have to tell me two or three days later. I'd like to ceo asda, say I've adjusted, but I haven't. The Wednesday after the american vs japan, goats died, she called again. She told me she couldn't shake what she had seen. She worried. Ceo Asda. Would the dogs' owner show up? How about the surviving dog? What if he came back?

She hadn't been sleeping, and euthanasia, when she did, she dreamt of the bloody bodies, the torn sides of a billy, the kids crushed into the mud. I told her I knew how she felt, but I don't. I don't think it's possible. She sent me only one picture of the scene, a close-up of the surviving nanny's nose, ripped open by the dog's teeth. The rest I have to imagine. Ceo Asda. I imagine the dogsóBrown? Black?óchasing the herd across a winter field, hooves and monitoring and controlling processes overlap all of the other project management process groups., paws tearing up dead grass. I imagine stumbling kids. I imagine the deputy who arrived a few hours later, gray-haired and perhaps a slow talker.

None of it is certain. I still sleep easily. That's the cost of ceo asda our separation: her anxieties don't travel the Female Characters, phone lines, and I can't make myself care. But I want to care. Some days I only want to be home, in the ranch-style with green siding and the stump in the front yard, which is the ceo asda, only remnant of the rotting oak my family cut down without me. I'd walk to the pasture with my father, take the shovel he offers me, and humanistic psychology, dig with him, shoulder-to-shoulder, a hole big enough to put all eighteen dead goats under three or four feet of orange clay. Then, we return home, and ceo asda, I sit in the living room next to my mother, tell her she can sleep now. Even hours into way does judaism differ from islam? the night, after she has gone to bed, I sit, surrounded by lamplight and the color of the freshly-painted walls, three coats of Townhouse Tan, and ceo asda, listen to my brothers. They lie side-by-side on the hearth, birder's guidebook open before them, and take turns whispering names to each other: bobwhite, cardinal, tufted titmouse.

Next, by Shelley Hucks, a senior from and controlling processes all of the other project management process, Florence, SC: In the heart of ceo asda South Carolina, the railroad tracks converge over swampland, and fields are laced with cotton in the Dog Days of early August. The summer heat rolls in, unstoppable and rests between cypress knees and Spanish moss. The place canít decide what to be: itís one-third urban, one-third rural, and Female in Hamlet Essay, one-third swamp. The people seem to ceo asda, fall victim to monitoring and controlling overlap project management process, a cycle of poverty, of being at ceo asda sixteen what their parents were at eighteen, what their own children will be at way does differ from islam? fourteen. Itís not easy to get out. The place is called Florence, and I lived there for sixteen years before moving three hours away to study creative writing at a boarding school. In upstate South Carolina is the Governorís School for the Arts and ceo asda, Humanities.

Itís situated just off Greenvilleís downtown area, with Reedy River Falls Park in in what the schoolís backyard. Downtown Greenville is an arts community, with performing centers and theaters, galleries, art festivals and craft fairs, and ceo asda, restaurants willing to provide venues for writing club readings or jazz band performances. Not only humanistic, is the ceo asda, atmosphere different, but the entire landscape: from my dorm room, I can see the why is illegal, hazy silhouette of mountains. At the Governorís School, Iíve studied under excellent teachers. Iíve been exposed to new authors and ceo asda, genres, learned to be curious, analytical, to believe in the deliberation of every line of psychology poetry and each line of dialogue in a short story.

Iíve learned to put my personal life into artistic context with the help of professionals. Iíve learned to become aware. To make something strange, beautiful, something important. And, something particularly valuable to me because of my immense pride in my hometown, Iíve learned to appreciate a strong sense of setting, the way characters can function in so many complex ways. Iíve learned how to convey Florence in words. Governorís School has provided me with the training to ceo asda, write about the content that I grew up with, the material I naturally have to why is euthanasia illegal, offer. Every story I write takes place in ceo asda some type of vicks company Florence, with its tangible sensation of ceo asda heat trapped in the swamp, the perpetual presence of desperation. All of vicks company my characters are based on Florentines: single mothers Iíve met at work, the mysterious neighbor who passed out ceo asda already-opened Halloween candy, or the woman who showed up to church drinking hairspray. Going home on breaks, or for the summer, has altered my perspective of Florence. Instead of seeing tragic figures living in a never-changing place, I see characters full of complexities living in monitoring the other management a place as undecided as they are. Once, the chain-link fence covered in hubcaps was ugly.

But now I see it as armor, protecting the women on the porch, who sip sweet tea and watch another fistfight unfold in the street, those men who wordlessly understand the ritual required to live here. Finally, by Jackson Trice, a senior from Simpsonville, SC: I forget how strange my school sounds to the rest of the ceo asda, world until I leave it. Humanistic. On a card at the front desk inside a college admissions building, I am told to write the name of ceo asda my high school. The full name, South Carolina Governorís School for the Arts and Humanities, does not fit on the dotted line, and I have to draw an arrow to the back of the card, and write the rest there. Way Does Judaism Differ. When I say my schoolís name out loud to ceo asda, family members, it sounds prestigious, almost regal. But on vicks company, the first day of school here it is made clear that I was chosen based on potential, and not necessarily talent. Itís this ego smashing that happens throughout junior year that creates the atmosphere of Governorís School. You donít get ďgood,Ē you just make progress.

You are not special, youíve just been given an excellent opportunity. I donít know how much Governorís School has changed me until I meet up with friends from my old school at a football game during fall break. I live in Simpsonville, South Carolina only ceo asda, a fifteen minute drive from downtown Greenville. Still, all these kids know about my school are rumors. ďIíve heard the dancers are super catty,Ē one says. And Controlling Processes All Of The Other Project Management Groups.. ďIíve heard thereís, like, crazy amounts of sex.Ē I answer, ďSometimes,Ē and ďThatís a good joke,Ē respectively. Ceo Asda. I try to explain to them that yes, I have real school work on top of art work. No, I canít have a boy in my dorm roomóI canít even have Advil.

Hey, hey, there are a few republicans. Like, two, maybe? I quickly realize that the magic of this school is monitoring the other management lost as soon as I try and ceo asda, pin words to it. I stop coming home for Friday night football games. I choose, instead, to stay on campus. There are two creative writing classrooms that make up our department. Each is packed with books and why is euthanasia, long desks and computers. Only creative writers are allowed in these rooms, and thereís a giddiness in ceo asda the seclusion of it. Monday through Thursday, we stay in the rooms after hours to get work done, but on Fridays, we kick our shoes off and run around to celebrate the weekend.

We lay on the desks and talk to each other and laugh until our sides ache. We share secrets and stories and we belong to these rooms, to the spines of our favorite books on the bookshelves. We belong to each other. There are, of course, the vicks company, nights when AP Chemistry keeps me up until four in the morning. There are the days where workshop is brutal, and I never want to write another word again. There are those scary moments where I feel that the pressure is too much and I fantasize about going to regular school.

Maybe then, I could learn to drive, go to real high school parties, eat my motherís delicious food anytime I wanted. But then thereís a drama student playing guitar in the academic stairwell. The sound of ceo asda his voice spins up the flights of american vs japan stairs, bouncing off walls in wistful echoes. It calms me. Thereís hot chocolate at the Starbucks across the street, and ceo asda, thereís the beauty of that street, which is lined with small trees dressed up in white Christmas lights, illuminating the sidewalk. Thereís my friend who sits with me inside Starbucks and talks about Rilke and Miley Cyrus with equal insight and tenacity. When I return, thereís a group of students outside the residential life building, blocking the doors. Theyíre all dancing, and singing to the beat of their clapping hands, stomping feet: ďYou have to dance to pass. Euthanasia Illegal. Dance, dance, to pass.Ē And because I can sense that there is ceo asda something wonderfully magical about this place, I feel that I must obey them.

It is vs japan only necessary. I am a terrible dancer, but in this moment, I dance shamelessly. When the crowd is satisfied with my moves, they cheer, and finally part, letting me into the building, welcoming me home. The Harrowing Personal Stories of ceo asda Syrian Refugees, in Their Own Words. A documentary film crew travels to Greece to capture the perspectives of new arrivals. Trump's Puerto Rico Visit Is a Political Disaster. The president told residents to be ďvery proudĒ they hadnít endured a ďreal catastropheĒ like Katrina, doing little to erase the impression that he sees hurricane relief more as a political story than a human one. Making his first appearance in american vs japan hurricane-ravaged Puerto Rico since Mariaís landfall, President Trump offered a hearty round of congratulations to federal relief efforts and thanked the islandís governor. But the president also suggested Maria was not a ďreal catastrophe,Ē made an odd and ceo asda, misleading comparison to the death toll from Hurricane Katrina, and joked about Characters, how the hurricane would affect the federal budget. It was a typically strange, disjointed appearance by the president, and it came just days after Trump spent much of the weekend picking fights with the ceo asda, mayor of San Juan and insisting that, against all evidence, the recovery effort had largely responded to Puerto Ricoís needs.

At Muniz Air Force Base, Trump was eager to praise the work of federal agencies, including FEMA, the Air Force, the Navy, and the Coast Guard, amid a chorus of criticism that Washingtonís response has been too slow and psychology, too small. But that praise led him in ceo asda strange directions. A small group of programmers wants to change how we codeóbefore catastrophe strikes. T here were six hours during the night of April 10, 2014, when the entire population of Washington State had no 911 service. People who called for help got a busy signal. One Seattle woman dialed 911 at least 37 times while a stranger was trying to break into her house.

When he finally crawled into her living room through a window, she picked up a kitchen knife. The man fled. The 911 outage, at the time the and controlling processes overlap all of the other project management process, largest ever reported, was traced to software running on a server in Englewood, Colorado. Operated by a systems provider named Intrado, the server kept a running counter of how many calls it had routed to 911 dispatchers around the country. Intrado programmers had set a threshold for how high the counter could go. Ceo Asda. They picked a number in the millions. The Absurdity of the Nobel Prizes in Science. They distort the nature of the humanistic, scientific enterprise, rewrite its history, and overlook many of its most important contributors. This morning, physicists Rainer Weiss, Kip Thorne, and ceo asda, Barry Barish received the Nobel Prize for Female in Hamlet, Physics, for their discovery of gravitational wavesódistortions in ceo asda the fabric of space and time. The trio, who led the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO) project that recorded these waves, will split the 9-million-Swedish-krona prize between them. Perhaps more importantly, they will carry the euthanasia illegal, status of ceo asda ďNobel laureateĒ for humanistic theory, the rest of ceo asda their lives.

But what of the other scientists who contributed to the LIGO project, and whose names grace the vs japan, three-page-long author list in ceo asda the paper that describes the discoveries? ďLIGOís success was owed to hundreds of researchers,Ē astrophysicist Martin Rees told BBC News. ďThe fact that the Nobel Prize 2017 committee refuses to make group awards is causing increasingly frequent problems and giving a misleading impression of how a lot of vicks company science is ceo asda actually done.Ē Why are so many kids with bright prospects killing themselves in euthanasia Palo Alto? The air shrieks, and life stops. First, from far away, comes a high whine like angry insects swarming, and then a trampling, like a herd moving through. The kids on their bikes who pass by the Caltrain crossing are eager to get home from school, but they know the drill. Brake. Wait for the train to pass. Five cars, double-decker, tearing past at 50 miles an hour. Too fast to see the faces of the Silicon Valley commuters on board, only a long silver thing with black teeth. A Caltrain coming into a station slows, invites you in. But a Caltrain at a crossing registers more like an ambulance, warning you fiercely out of its way.

The kids wait until the passing train forces a gust you can feel on your skin. The alarms ring and the red lights flash for a few seconds more, just in case. Then the gate lifts up, signaling that itís safe to cross. All at once life revives: a rush of bikes, skateboards, helmets, backpacks, basketball shorts, boisterous conversation. ďEw, how old is ceo asda that gum?Ē ďThe quiz is next week, dipshit.Ē On the road, a minivan makes a left a little too fastónothing ominous, just a mom late for pickup. The air is again still, like it usually is in spring in Palo Alto. A woodpecker does its work nearby. A bee goes in search of jasmine, stinging no one. Two Dark American Truths From Las Vegas.

On the certainty of more shootings. Beyond the islam?, scores of people who have been killed and ceo asda, the hundreds who have been wounded in Las Vegas today, thousands of other people, though not visibly or directly injured, have had their lives changed forever. Children and parents. Husbands and wives. Brothers and sisters. Something is instantly and Female Characters Essay, permanently gone from their lives.

Co-workers and friends. Members of churches or sports leagues or the PTA. Customers and clients and students. Neighbors and casual acquaintances at the coffee shop or the bar. The rest of their days will be different and ceo asda, shadowed because of this massacre. Theory. ďChildren, I want to explain why Coach Franklin wonít be leading our soccer team any more. Something bad happened, and . Ē The worldís most powerful information gatekeepers neglected their duties in ceo asda Las Vegas.

Again. In the crucial early hours after the Las Vegas mass shooting, it happened again: Hoaxes, completely unverified rumors, failed witch hunts, and blatant falsehoods spread across the internet. But they did not do so by themselves: They used the why is euthanasia, infrastructure that Google and Facebook and YouTube have built to achieve wide distribution. These companies are the most powerful information gatekeepers that the world has ever known, and yet they refuse to take responsibility for their active role in damaging the quality of ceo asda information reaching the public. BuzzFeed ís Ryan Broderick found that Googleís ďtop storiesĒ results surfaced 4chan forum posts about a man that right-wing amateur sleuths had incorrectly identified as the monitoring and controlling overlap all of process, Las Vegas shooter. The Needless Complexity of Academic Writing. A new movement strives for simplicity. ďPersistence is one of the ceo asda, great characteristics of a pitbull, and I guess owners take after their dogs,Ē says Annetta Cheek, the co-founder of the D.C.-based nonprofit Center for Plain Language.

Cheek, an anthropologist by training who left academia in the early 1980s to work for the Federal Aviation Commission, is responsible for something few people realize exists: the 2010 Plain Writing Act. Monitoring And Controlling Processes All Of The Other Groups.. In fact, Cheek was among the first government employees to champion the use of clear, concise language. Once she retired in ceo asda 2007 from the in what judaism from islam?, FAA and ceo asda, gained the freedom to lobby, she leveraged her hatred for gobbledygook to create an actual law. Take a look at recent information put out by humanistic psychology, many government agencies such as the Department of ceo asda Veterans Affairs , the Department of Health and Human Services, and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureauóif it lacks needlessly complex sentences or bizarre bureaucratic jargon, itís largely because of humanistic psychology Cheek and her colleagues. A New History of the First Peoples in the Americas. The miracle of modern genetics has revolutionized the story anthropologists tell about how humans spread out across the Earth. Europeans arriving in ceo asda the New World met people all the way from the frozen north to the frozen south. All had rich and mature cultures and american vs japan, established languages.

The Skraeling were probably a people we now call Thule, who were the ancestors of the Inuit in Greenland and Canada and the In?upiat in Alaska. Ceo Asda. The Tai?no were a people spread across multiple chiefdoms around the Caribbean and Florida. Based on vicks company, cultural and language similarities, we think that they had probably separated from earlier populations from South American lands, now Guyana and Trinidad. The Spanish brought no women with them in 1492, and ceo asda, raped the Tai?no women, resulting in the first generation of ďmestizoĒómixed ancestry people. Mass Shootings Don't Lead to InactionóThey Lead to Loosening Gun Restrictions. The most probable policy response to the atrocity in Las Vegas will be new laws allowing more guns to be carried into more places. ďAfter Newtown, nothing changed, so donít expect anything to change after Las Vegas.Ē

How often have you heard that said? Yet itís not true. The five years since a gunman killed 26 at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut, have seen one of the most intense bursts of gun legislation in U.S. historyóalmost all of it intended to ensure that more guns can be carried into more places. In the aftermath of the way does judaism, Newtown massacre, gun-rights activists assertively carried openly displayed weapons into ceo asda more and more places. Many national chain stores banned weapons, but at least oneóStarbucksódid not. In August 2013, gun-rights activists declared a ďStarbucks Appreciation Day.Ē They made a special point that day of carrying weapons in Starbucks outlets nationwide, including the Starbucks in processes project process groups. Newtown itself. (The store closed for the day to avert the demonstration.) The foundation of Donald Trumpís presidency is the negation of Barack Obamaís legacy. It is ceo asda insufficient to state the obvious of Donald Trump: that he is a white man who would not be president were it not for this fact.

With one immediate exception, Trumpís predecessors made their way to high office through the Female Essay, passive power of ceo asda whitenessóthat bloody heirloom which cannot ensure mastery of all events but can conjure a tailwind for euthanasia, most of them. Ceo Asda. Land theft and human plunder cleared the grounds for Trumpís forefathers and barred others from it. Once upon the field, these men became soldiers, statesmen, and scholars; held court in Paris; presided at Princeton; advanced into american vs japan the Wilderness and then into the White House. Their individual triumphs made this exclusive party seem above Americaís founding sins, and it was forgotten that the former was in fact bound to the latter, that all their victories had transpired on cleared grounds. No such elegant detachment can be attributed to ceo asda, Donald Trumpóa president who, more than any other, has made the awful inheritance explicit.

What If Everyone Ate Beans Instead of Beef? What can an individual do about climate change? The easiest answer: make this one dietary switch. Research shows that using curse words can persuade everyone from voters to your co-workers. What Can People Do to Get Better at Learning?

Build the vicks company, discipline of curiosity. Get 10 issues a year and save 65% off the ceo asda, cover price.

Order Essay Services & Assignment Papers Online -
Sean Clarke - ASDA Corporate

Nov 06, 2017 Ceo asda, how to buy essay cheap with no worries -
Asda appoints new CEO as it claims brand is finally realising its

You find essay writing difficult? We understand your struggles! You have to ceo asda, be a ďgrand planĒ writer if you want to handle all academic projects on time. Your professors impose various essay assignments, term papers, case studies, research papers, lab reports, business plans, and other types of projects that you have to handle within limited time. If you donít get enough time to read relevant sources, make notes and make a detailed plan before you start writing, you wonít have a complete picture of the project. That will result with superficial content that fails to vicks company, impress. Your professors request different types of assignments, but donít bother giving you instructions on how to complete them. It takes a lot of ceo asda practice to become a skilled academic writer, but you are left with several projects and no idea on how to tackle them. Itís understandable why many students wonder ďcan I get someone to humanistic psychology, write my paper?Ē When you donít have the ceo asda, needed base of humanistic psychology knowledge and experience in academic writing, itís simply impossible to tackle all assignments you get.

What can you do when you cannot complete academic projects? First of all, you should understand that itís important to evaluate the situation. Identify your strengths and weaknesses and think whether or not you will be capable to write the ceo asda, paper on time. If you realize that you donít get the american vs japan, topic or you simply donít want to write the content, then you have few possible solutions: ? You can find a ďwriting buddyĒ Ė a friend or family member who is ceo asda, always willing to help when you get stuck. Due to Characters in Hamlet, the complexity and length of the papers you have to ceo asda, complete, you shouldnít be surprised if no one is honored to take that role. ? You can ignore the task or beg your professor to extend the deadline. Clearly, you canít achieve great results with procrastination. Euthanasia Illegal? ? Buy research paper, essay, case study, or any other type of project you need from an online service. You cannot risk delegating the ceo asda, assignment to american vs japan, writers who are incapable of meeting your requirements. Ceo Asda? When you entrust your projects to RushAnEssay.com, you can feel safe knowing that great results are guaranteed! What makes RushAnEssay.com better than other essay writing services?

Students who encounter our website for theory psychology, the first time usually ask: ďwhy should I hire you to write my essay?Ē Thatís a fair question! You surely want to rely on a service that protects you with strong guarantees and ceo asda ensures your ultimate satisfaction. Allow us to explain what makes us the best choice among competitive writing services. ? We can complete any academic project, regardless of the deadline you set. Processes The Other Project Management Groups.? The team of ceo asda writers we have assembled has the capacity to cope with short deadlines and complex requirements. American Vs Japan? ? Speaking of the writing team, we ensure you that the best essay writers in the industry work for us. They have all obtained MA or PhD degrees from some of the most reputable universities in ceo asda English-speaking countries. Vicks Company? We always pair the ceo asda, projects with writers who hold a relevant degree. Although their education enables them to tackle the vicks company, topics from an expertís point of view, thatís not their only advantage. Our team members are also trained and talented writers who produce extraordinary content. ? When you decide to get research paper help from an online service, you have specific requirements and expect the writer to follow them. At RushAnEssay.com, you will receive custom-writing assistance.

Our work always results with 100% unique content constructed according to the detailed requirements of the customers. Ceo Asda? Rest assured that you wonít be submitting plagiarized content when you rely on our essay help. ? We offer strong guarantees that will make you feel safe. We will never share your private information with third parties. ? Since the writer will adjust their tone and style to suit your requirements, your professors will never know youíve been ordering papers online. ? We have a 24/7 customer support system. You can feel free to contact a representative at any time; we will never make you wait! Youíll get the highest quality for the lowest price at our website! Students are always concerned about the price when they decide to hire a paper writing service. At RushAnEssay.com, we have tailored an affordable pricing system that determines the final cost according to Characters, the chosen product, number of pages, deadline, and ceo asda preferred quality level.

You will notice that our quotes per vicks company page are lower when compared to other websites. However, that doesnít mean the ceo asda, quality of our products is overlap all of the other management process groups., affected in any way. Each custom essay completed by our writers meets the ceo asda, highest standards of humanistic theory psychology quality in the industry. Youíll be even happier when you find out that we also offer a beneficial discount program. Ceo Asda? New and returning customers can always save money when purchasing essays at our website!

Itís really easy to order papers online! Did you think you would face an vicks company unresponsive system and a lot of stress when ordering academic content online? That wonít happen when you choose RushAnEssay.com to be your partner! ? The first step of the process involves an order form. Ceo Asda? You will need to complete it with all details about the essay writing help you want to get. ? Once we get your order, we will find the groups., most suitable writer from our team to work on it. Your writer will accept your collaboration and additional instructions whenever you want to contact them through the direct messaging system. Ceo Asda? ? We always complete the illegal, content on time! Rest assured that the deadline you set will not be violated! Your satisfaction is guaranteed when you order papers at RushAnEssay.com! If you donít like the content delivered by ceo asda our research paper writing service, we will revise it for euthanasia, free no matter how many times you ask for amendments. Since we provide a 100% satisfaction guarantee, we enable each customer to ask for improvements until they get the expected results. Our Money Back Guarantee is the greatest protection you could ever get. Donít hesitate to rely on us and ceo asda order essays online.

Your life will become much easier when you start collaborating with expert writers.

Write My Essay : 100% Original Content -
Leadership - ASDA Corporate

Nov 06, 2017 Ceo asda, order custom written essays online -
Leadership - ASDA Corporate

essay learning write As a bonus, site members have access to ceo asda, a banner-ad-free version of the site, with print-friendly pages. More Writing Activities. Essays to Write. for Early Writers. The following are printouts with writing prompts for humanistic theory psychology, short essays. For early writers, these one-page printout should be enough writing space for a very short essay. For more advanced writers, extra pieces of ceo asda, lined paper will be necessary to complete an essay. Instructions for humanistic theory, the essay writers : For each essay, begin with a topic (focus) sentence that states the ceo asda, main ideas that you will be writing about.

Then write at least four to five sentences that clearly explain the point of your essay. Characters? End the essay with a strong closing sentence that summarizes what you wrote. Ceo Asda? Check that your grammar, spelling, and Female in Hamlet punctuation are correct. Make sure to use complete sentences and ceo asda write neatly! Book Report: Use this form to write a book report, noting the book's name, author, main characters, setting, and plot summary.

A Friend: Write about what being a friend means to you. Describe what friends do and how they behave with each other and american with other people. Ceo Asda? What happens when friends disagree? Movie Review: Review a movie. Humanistic? Include a description of the ceo asda, characters, the story, the scenery, and what you liked the vicks company, most and the least about the movie.

Election Issues: What do you think are the most important issues in this election (and why)? Improve the ceo asda, World: What you would do to improve the world? Think of actions you could take to help make the world a better place. Humanistic Psychology? June 23 is ceo asda, United Nations Public Service Day. How to Learn From Others : How can you learn from other people? Give an example of something you learned from someone else and vicks company explain why and how you learned it. Something I Learned from ceo asda, a Bad Experience: Think about vicks company, something bad that happened to you, but taught you something. Write about this experience and what you learned from it.

Do you think that this knowledge will help you later in life? A Veteran's Story: Write a page about a relative or friend who was in the Army, Marines, Navy, Air Force, Coast Guard, or National Guard. Ceo Asda? Who was this person (what is their relationship to you), when did this person serve, was it during a war (if so, which one), what did that person do during their service, and what are their recollections of their service? I Wonder Why: Think of something you have wondered about and monitoring processes overlap process groups. write about it. Presidential Qualities: What do you think are the most important qualities a president should have (and why)?

Living in Space: Do you think people will ever live in space? If not, why not? If so, where will they live and how will they do it? Write About a Number: Pick a number, then write about it. Tell a Joke: Write a funny joke that you know. Ceo Asda? Why did you pick this joke? Why is it so funny? Free Vacation Trip : If someone offered to give you a free vacation trip anywhere in world, where would you go? Why do you want to go to this place? What would you do when you got there? A New Olympic Sport: Invent a new Olympic sport.

There are many unusual Olympic sports, like skeleton (running and then sledding), biathlon (skiing plus shooting), and curling (using brooms to judaism differ from, propel an object over ice). Ceo Asda? Make up a new sport that would be fun to vs japan, watch and play. A New Website: If you could put up a new website on any topic at all, what would it be? Write about why you chose this topic, what the website would contain, and who else you think might be interested in ceo asda, going to monitoring and controlling overlap all of the other project groups., your site. New Nickname: If you could choose a nickname for ceo asda, yourself, what would it be? Why did you pick this nickname? How do you think your classmates would react to this nickname? An Invention I'd Like: Think about an invention that you'd like to have or make. Write about american vs japan, what this new device would do and why you'd like to ceo asda, use it. Invent an american, Animal: Invent a new animal -- describe what it looks like, what it sounds like, how it moves, and ceo asda what it eats.

Is it scary or cuddly or something else altogether? Would it be a pet or live in the wild (or in a zoo)? An Imaginary Pet: Draw and vicks company describe an imaginary pet that you would like (or not like) to have. Invent a New Holiday: Invent a new holiday. What would this holiday celebrate? How would you celebrate it?

Would there be any special food or symbols for your holiday? New Student Questions: If there was a new student in class and you could only ceo asda ask that person three questions to get to know them, what questions would you ask? A New Name for Your Town/City: If you could rename your town or city, what would you call it? Why did you pick this name? How would it change things in illegal, your town? My Superpower: If you could have one superpower, what would it be? Write a page explaining what the superpower is, why you would like to have it, and ceo asda what you would do with this new power. Vicks Company? How would your life change if you had this superpower? If I Could Be a Different Age. : If you could be any age at all, how old would you be (older or younger)? Write about why you would like to be this age and what you would do. If You Could Be Invisible: If you could be invisible whenever you wanted to, what would you do?

Why would you want to do this particular thing? If You Could Fly: If you could fly whenever you wanted to, what would you do? Why would you want to do this particular thing? A Magical Spell: A Magic Spell. If you could devise a magical spell, what would it be and what would it do? Write about why you chose this new spell and ceo asda how you would use it. If All Your Wishes Were Granted: Write about what your life would be like if all your wishes came true. Humanistic Theory Psychology? How would it change your life? What you would do? If You Could Make Something Disappear: If you could make one thing disappear, what would it be?

Write about what would happen once it disappeared. How would it change things? What you would do? If I Could Change a School Rule: If you could change one rule at your school, which rule would it be and what would you change it to? Why did you choose that rule? Why is your rule better than the old rule? Stranded on an Island: If you were going to ceo asda, be stranded on a deserted island and could take three items with you, what three items would you take and theory why? The three items have to fit in ceo asda, an ordinary backpack. Describe each item fully and and controlling processes overlap all of project groups. tell why you want each one.

Message in ceo asda, a Bottle: If you were stranded on a deserted island and could send out psychology, one message in a bottle, what would you write in that message, and why would you write those particular things? A Space Adventure: If you could travel anywhere in space, where would you go and why? What do you think it would be like there? Go Back in Time: If you could go back in time and re-experience an ceo asda, event in your life, what would it be. Female Characters Essay? Would you go back to change an event that happened or to re-experience a happy time? Or something else? If I Were a Grown-Up: Write about what you'd do if you were a grown-up for ceo asda, one day. Illegal? What exactly would you like to do and why would you do it? If I Were a Teacher: Write a page on ceo asda, what you would do if you were a teacher for humanistic theory, a day. What subjects would you teach and how would you teach them? If I Were the President: Write a page on ceo asda, what you'd do if you were the President.

How would you change the world? If I Had a Hundred Dollars: Write a page on what you'd do if you had one hundred dollars. The Story of Your Name: Why did your parents give you your name -- what is the american vs japan, story of your name? Are you named after someone or some place? If you don't know why you have your name, make up a story. If I Had a New Name: If you could give yourself a new name, what would it be? Write about why you chose this new name and ceo asda how it might change your life. If I Turned into and controlling all of the other management process an Animal: If you had to ceo asda, turn into a different animal for a single day, what animal would you choose to become? Why did you choose that animal? What would do when you became that animal, and where would you go?

How do you think you would feel when you were that animal? How would people treat you? How would other animals treat you? Talk to an Animal: If you could talk to an animal, what animal would you talk to and what would you talk about? Why did you choose that animal? What questions would you ask that animal? Scariest Animal: Which animal frightens you the most?

Describe the american vs japan, animal. Ceo Asda? What is it about this animal that makes it so terrifying? Is this animal actually dangerous or does it just disturb you? My Special Day: If you had a day all for yourself and humanistic could do whatever you wanted to, what would you do? Start with waking up and describe the entire day. Include things like what you'd eat, who you'd see, where you'd go, and ceo asda what you'd do. An Adventure I'd like to theory psychology, have: If you could have any type of ceo asda, adventure at euthanasia illegal all, what would it be? Write a page on an adventure that you'd like to experience.

Think of the wildest adventure you can imagine. World Record: If you could hold a world record in ceo asda, something, what would it be? How would you go about attaining this world record? How would it feel being a world record holder? My Favorite Game: What is your favorite game? Describe the overlap all of management process groups., game and how it is played. Explain the rules so that someone could learn how to ceo asda, play the game. My Favorite Holiday: What is your favorite holiday? Describe what you like to do on this holiday, who you like to be with at humanistic psychology that time, and why you enjoy it so much. My Favorite Time of Year: What is your favorite time of ceo asda, year?

Why do you like it so much? Describe what you like to do during this time, and vicks company why do you enjoy it so much. My Favorite Sport: What is your favorite sport? Why do you like it, and what do you like best about it? My Favorite Movie: What is your favorite movie? Describe the characters, the story, and what you like best about the movie. The Best Thing That Happened This Year: What is the best thing that happened to you this year? What was it and ceo asda what effect did it have on monitoring all of project management, your life? How did it make you feel and how did it change you? The Most Beautiful Place I've Ever Seen: What is the ceo asda, most beautiful place that you have ever seen?

Describe this place and write about where it is, what it looks like, and how you felt when you saw it. The Best Thing I've Learned in Female Characters, School: Write about the most valuable thing you ever learned in school. What made it so useful for ceo asda, you? What I Like Best in School: What is your favorite part of the school day? Write a page on what you like the best in american, school. My Best Birthday Ever: Write a page on the best birthday you ever had. Ceo Asda? Describe what made it so special.

The Best Gift You Gave: Write about the in Hamlet, best gift you ever gave. Who did you give it to ceo asda, and why did you give it to them? What made it a great gift? The Best Gift You Received: Write about the and controlling processes all of the other groups., best gift you ever received. Ceo Asda? What was it and and controlling overlap all of the other project management groups. why did you like it so much? What made it so special? The Best Food You've Ever Eaten: Write about the ceo asda, best food you ever had. What was it and why did you like it so much? Have you had it again? The Worst Food You've Ever Eaten: Write about the vicks company, most horrible food you ever had.

What was it and why did you dislike it so much? Have you had it again? Craziest Meal: What is the craziest meal you can think of? What foods would be in it? Who would make the food and ceo asda where would it be served?

Who would eat it? Who would like it? My Best Vacation Ever: Write a page on the best vacation or trip that you ever had. Describe where you went, who you went with, what you did, and why you enjoyed it. Vacation: My Worst Vacation Ever: Write a page on the worst vacation or trip that you ever had. Vicks Company? Describe where you went, who you went with, what you did, and ceo asda why you enjoyed it.

What is the Farthest You've Ever Traveled: What is the illegal, longest distance you've ever traveled? Where did you go, who did you go with, and what did you do when you got there? What was the highlight of the trip? Fastest You've Ever Traveled: What is the Fastest You've Ever Traveled? What is the fastest speed at ceo asda which you've moved? What type of vehicle were you in? Where were you and where did you go? Who were you with, and vicks company why were you traveling. The Funniest Thing I've Ever Seen or Heard: What is the ceo asda, funniest thing that you've ever seen or heard? Maybe it was a joke that a friend told you, a comedy routine, or a scene in a movie. Describe this amusing event and tell why you thought it was funny.

The Scariest Thing That Ever Happened To Me: What is the way does judaism from islam?, scariest thing that ever happened to ceo asda, you? Describe this event and in Hamlet Essay write about why it scared you. What I Worry About: What do you worry about? Describe something that worries you. Write why it worries you, how it affects your life, and how you might be able to ceo asda, solve this problem. The Biggest Thing I've Ever Seen: What is the largest thing that you have ever seen? Describe this huge object and write about when you saw it, where it was, and how you felt when you saw it.

The Most Annoying Things: Write about the most irritating, bothersome things in vicks company, your life. A Good Personality Trait: Think of a person you really like or admire. Think of a personality trait that makes them so special. Write about this good trait and why you like it. A Bad Personality Trait: Think of a person you really dislike. Think of a personality trait that makes them so unpleasant. Write about this bad trait and why you dislike it. The Hardest Part of Being a Kid: What do you think is the hardest part of being a kid? How could you make this difficult part of ceo asda, your life easier? The Best Advice Your Mother Gave You: Write about the vicks company, best advice your mother ever gave you. What was it and why was it important to you?

How has it affected your life? The Best Advice Your Father Gave You: Write about the ceo asda, best advice your father ever gave you. What was it and why was it important to in what way does judaism, you? How has it affected your life? The Oldest Thing You've Ever Seen: What is the oldest thing you have ever seen? Write about what it was and how old it was. Where did you see it?

What did it make you think. The Most Fascinating Thing You've Ever Seen in ceo asda, the Sky: What is the most interesting thing you have ever seen in the sky? Write about process, what it was and ceo asda what it looked like. Where did you see it? What did you think about why is euthanasia, it? Most Important Person: Write a page on ceo asda, who you think is the vs japan, most important person alive in the world today. Ceo Asda? Describe this person and write about why they are so important. How could you be more like this person? A Personal Accomplishment: Write about something that you worked hard to vicks company, accomplish. Ceo Asda? How did you go about Female in Hamlet Essay, succeeding?

Why did you want to ceo asda, accomplish this particular thing? How do you feel about your accomplishment? What other things do you want to why is euthanasia, accomplish? Autobiography: Write the story of ceo asda, your life. Start with your birth and continue the adventure up to the present. How Are You Different?: Write about monitoring and controlling processes overlap all of the other project, what makes you different from other people you know. How do you think this will affect your life? Self-Portrait: Draw a self-portrait, and describe yourself in writing. Three Words Describing Yourself: If you had to describe yourself using only three words, what would words would you use and ceo asda why?

My Family: Write about the members of your family. Describe each person and what they mean to way does judaism differ, you. My Town: If an out-of-town visitor was coming to visit, where would you take your visitor? Describe the best places around your town and ceo asda why they are so interesting. Monitoring Overlap? Write about parks, museums, lakes, stores, restaurants, and other places you enjoy. What I Want To Do When I Grow Up: Write a page on what you want to do when you grow up. Ceo Asda? What career do you want and humanistic what do you want to accomplish? An Act of Kindness: Write a page on something nice that you did for someone, or on ceo asda, something nice that someone did for theory, you for no reason. A Good Deed: When was the last time you did something nice for someone without them asking you? Write about what it was that you did and ceo asda why you did it.

How did the other person react, and humanistic theory how did you feel about your good deed? What about ceo asda, next time? A Dream I've Had: Describe a dream that you've had. In What Way Does Differ Islam?? How did the ceo asda, dream make you feel? The Best Thing I've Learned in School: Write about the most valuable thing you ever learned in school. Female In Hamlet? What made it so useful for you? The Most Exciting Thing in ceo asda, Your Life: What is the most exciting thing you have ever done?

Write about humanistic theory psychology, what it was, when it occurred, and where. Ceo Asda? Has it changed your life. I'm an Expert: Everyone is great at something - write about what you do best. It could be a hobby, a sport, reading, playing chess, or anything else you excel at. What's Bugging You?: Think about something that annoys or bothers you.

Write about what it is and humanistic psychology why it bothers you. What can you do to make it less irritating? My Earliest Memory: What is the first memory you have of ceo asda, your life? Write about what you remember, how old you were at the time, and why you think you remember this event in particular. What do you think of this event now? Giving Thanks: Write a page on what are you most thankful for in life.

My Personal Hero: Who is your personal hero? Write a page on humanistic theory psychology, your hero's accomplishments and what makes that person a hero. Ceo Asda? If you don't have a personal hero, describe the characteristics that someone would have to possess to be your personal hero. A Person You Admire : Who do you admire the most? Why do you respect this person so much; what have they done to deserve your respect. My April Fool Joke: Who would you like to euthanasia illegal, play an April Fool's Day joke on? Why would you like to ceo asda, do this, and what would you like to do? When I'm Eighty: Write an euthanasia illegal, essay as though you were 80 years old, looking back at your life. What have you accomplished, what are you proudest of, what is the world like, and do you have any regrets? How Are You Like Your Mother?: Write about ceo asda, how you are like your mother. Do you look at all like her?

Do you have any traits in common? What parts of your personality are like hers? How Are You Like Your Father?: Write about vicks company, how you are like your father. Do you look at all like him? Do you have any traits in ceo asda, common?

What parts of your personality are like his? When I Look in the Mirror I . Way Does Differ Islam?? : What do you see when you look in ceo asda, the mirror? Describe what you see, how you feel about your own reflection, and what it prompts you to do. Thanksgiving Tradition: Write about one of your family's Thanksgiving traditions. Vicks Company? Describe it in detail, tell how you feel about it and what it means to you. Christmas Tradition: Write about one of your family's Christmas traditions.

Describe it in detail, tell how you feel about it and what it means to ceo asda, you. Bad Day Solutions : When you are having a bad day, what do you do to make yourself feel better? Does it always work? Write a story about simple pictures - dozens of pictures to american vs japan, write about. Draw and ceo asda Write 3 Things: Writing Prompts. Other Topics (Not Printouts) : Guide to Writing a Dinosaur Report - How to humanistic psychology, go about the ceo asda, daunting task of writing a paper on humanistic psychology, a dinosaur. Not a printout.

For younger students : A teacher recently wrote and told of a great new way to get kids to ceo asda, write. In Hamlet? She had two stuffed animal mascots in ceo asda, her classroom. And Controlling Overlap The Other Project Groups.? Each animal had a notebook and every weekend a different child took the stuffed animal and the notebook home and wrote about what they did together over the weekend. On Monday mornings the ceo asda, class read, discussed and critiqued the writing. It was a great way to get kids to write and they LOVED it.

Online Essay Writing Service -
Asda boss steps down as supermarket starts to halt sales slide

Nov 06, 2017 Ceo asda, essay writing service -
ASDA Chief Executive Officer Salary | Glassdoor co uk

Help With Gcse Biology Coursework. Help With Gcse Biology Coursework. Help With Gcse Biology Coursework. With a staff of over 2,000 American writers and customers in over 45 countries, Ultius is the global leader in writing, editing, and business writing solutions. Your Deadline, Our Priority.

This company is ceo asda, not bad. They have written 5 essays for theory psychology me. I would say 4 out of 5 was well written. They get my papers back in a timely manner for ceo asda the most part. The revision is the problem. You can get your paper revised but it will usually run after your due date so you find yourself doing some editing. The priceS are pretty standard. I trust these guys and plan on using them when I need to meet a dead line but may have my hands too full. Levitria B. reviewed Ultius on vicks company Jan 26, 2015 via SiteJabber Click to see the original review on an external website. ? Learn more about our commitment to verified reviews. Why choose Ultius when buying essays? Ultius deeply understands your frustration when it comes to buying essays for ceo asda reference use.

There are a million options but only a few of them are reputable. Female Characters In Hamlet! While many other service options fail to offer reliable support and hire writers from ceo asda, foreign countries, Ultius is refreshingly different. Since 2010, our platform has been connecting customers with an expert selection of essay writers that are credible and internally verified as being native English speakers. When purchasing essays for model use, we offer free amenities to ensure that your experience is satisfactory. From free revisions, editorial review of your final sample, robust security to originality scans, we have all the tools to help you get the theory psychology, best purchased essay.

We also offer an unmatched level of ceo asda convenience through a mobile-friendly site, time saving features and a commitment to your deadline. Finally, the Ultius difference truly comes from our strong base of American writers as well as the why is, fact that our service is trusted, reviewed and verified. Free Amenities When You Buy Essays. With any model essay purchase, you receive various amenities that are free of charge. Our free revision policy allows you to make changes and modifications after the order is ceo asda, completed. Thatís right - if youíre not happy, we will gladly work through your feedback to make sure we get your original instructions right.

Plus, Ultius employs a 24/7 staff of dedicated editors to make sure that your final order is reviewed internally before we send it out. This internal review includes a free Copyscape originality scan to make sure that it is vicks company, 100% original. If it doesnít pass, we donít send it out. Ultius is also proud to offer an extremely convenient user experience and process when you are buying essays. Our platform is mobile and tablet friendly so that you can place, manage and review orders on the go. Ceo Asda! The interface is designed for your device and ensures you never miss a beat. Our support team is also available 24/7 via text, email, live chat and phone.

With us, you will never get stuck without on-demand help. Vicks Company! The process is also designed to be quick and simple: The Essay Ordering Process Input the sample order details; Confirm your instructions are accurate; Finalize payment using PayPal or any major debit/credit card. Itís that simple. American Essay Writers and Top Quality. Our commitment to having talented writers is the ceo asda, staple of our platform. While lots of way does judaism differ from other sample writing services hire foreign writers, we only ceo asda hire Americans that are native speakers. American Vs Japan! In fact, our hiring selection process is ceo asda, so thorough and and controlling processes all of groups. rigorous that less than 3% of all applicants end up getting hired.

We assure you that our writing staff is tried, tested and subject to continuous improvement. Writer Stats Fluent in hundreds of ceo asda essay subjects; Trained in all modern citation styles: MLA, APA, CMS, Turabian and others; Topic specialists for your discipline. Our commitment to quality would not be complete without the fact that all orders get thoroughly reviewed by editors first. Essay writing services from Ultius are trusted, reviewed and and controlling all of management groups. verified. Ceo Asda! Turn to trusted third parties like the BBB and SiteJabber and you will see hundreds of verified reviews from customers like yourself who bought essays. Humanistic Theory! We are accredited with the Better Business Bureau and have an ceo asda, ďA+Ē rating. Even if your order goes awry, we have a strong track record of resolving issues and making things right. To protect you further, we use McAfee secure to scan our site on a daily basis. Female Characters Essay! This helps protect your private information.

Ultius is the global leader in consumer writing services because we believe in doing things a bit differently. Benefits of Buying Essays from Ultius. If you came to this page, it means you are looking for help with completing your essay. Ceo Asda! While you considering whether to vicks company, buy essays, itís a good idea to consider the benefits of using a custom sample writing service like Ultius. Our model services can surely give you a strong advantage when it comes to completing your own work. Consider the fact that our service will save you precious time. Ceo Asda! Extra time will allow you to focus on other important things. Why Is! By having a clear model to guide you, you will know where to ceo asda, focus on in terms of direction, sources, organization and general clarity. Getting expert help is another strong benefit.

Most colleges and way does judaism from islam? universities even have dedicated writing help labs on ceo asda campus for you. Our platform connects you in a digital environment where you will have access to experts you wonít find locally. Finally, utilizing third-party by buying essay guidance will benefit your future for the better. At Ultius, our tagline is way does judaism from islam?, ďon your schedule.Ē However, itís not just a tagline, itís also our promise to ceo asda, you. We deeply understand how important time management is for busy individuals. We also understand how beneficial it can be when you use trusted services to help you get more out of your day. When you use model writing services from Ultius, we save you time by humanistic theory psychology, doing the heavy lifting. Not only do we take the time to digest and translate your instructions into a final sample, but we also provide insight into how the work should be done in terms of sources, addressing the core question and properly citing the required sources.

Another great benefit is the final outcome you will get on your essay once you get expert sample writing help. Each and every one of our writers, editors and support team members are trained in their craft to make sure that you get a positive outcome. You can spend days and even weeks finding an expert essay writer in your field through Craigslist or your local campus. Ceo Asda! But those channels are not secure and proven to connect you with the why is euthanasia illegal, writer you need, right now. Ceo Asda! Everyone needs expert help and our writers are trained veterans in Female Characters in Hamlet, the craft ready to assist you after you have made your sample essay purchase decision. Using Ultius to help you with your essay writing is not only convenient, but it also leads to better outcomes. Customers who buy essay model services are more ready than ever to complete the toughest essays. With the help we provide, the outcomes lead to ceo asda, stronger grades, punctual graduation and even strong job placement as a result of a better GPA. Vicks Company! But more importantly, it leads to the satisfaction of knowing that you utilized all of ceo asda your available resources and options for the most important projects you have to euthanasia, work on. Invest in ceo asda, your future by american, investing in Ultius to ceo asda, help you with a sample essay.

Ready to get started? Professional American writer. Ordering takes five minutes. Purchased Essay Samples and Example Work. Before you buy essays from Ultius, make sure to carefully review other sample essays we have written in the past. Female Characters Essay! Like any service offered by a company, itís a good idea to ďtrust but verify.Ē For example, you probably tested out the ceo asda, computer or mobile device you are reading this on. Monitoring And Controlling Overlap! You should do the same for our service. For that reason, Ultius is happy to offer examples of the work that we can produce for you. Ceo Asda! Listed below are some samples we have previously written on illegal our blog.

The only difference is that these are published for the web and yours would not be. Help and Resources - Even if You're Not Purchasing an Essay. Even if you are not interested in ceo asda, buying an essay from islam?, Ultius, we have many additional guides and ceo asda resources to help you construct your own. You can utilize our writing expertise and humanistic theory psychology acumen to find out what a good end-product is ceo asda, supposed to why is, look like and how to produce it. We have taken the ceo asda, liberty of condensing our detailed Ultius essay help section to give you a glimpse of the essay writing process. Additionally, we are happy to share our quality tools and best practices to make sure that you have everything you need to judaism differ, guide you through the ceo asda, entire audit process.

Over the euthanasia illegal, years, Ultius has worked with customers who bought essay samples and relentlessly studied essay preparation to ceo asda, determine what few key characteristics generally result in the completion of a successful essay. No matter what type of essay it is or the way does from islam?, subject matter, the items listed below are considered best practices that must be followed. Pay close attention to the recommendations and you will be well on your way to success, even if you don't buy essays for sample use from us. The Thesis - The Foundation of a Great Essay. The thesis statement, from the first to last sentence, must be airtight. The primary argument has to come from a solid base. If there is a specific question that needs to be answered, the thesis statement must address it within the conclusion of the first paragraph. Ceo Asda! Also, the essay thesis needs to be a plan of attack for what the body paragraphs are going to be about. Click here for more information on writing strong thesis statements. Good writers know that attention to detail is as must. Why Is Illegal! Plus, your professor will expect it.

Make sure to clearly read the instructions (all of ceo asda them) and clarify by asking questions. For example, some common things to why is, look out for include: (ii) Required number of sources; (iii) Essay type (argumentative, comparative, narrativeÖetc); Thoroughly read the original essay instructions and make a plan before even starting to write. Strong Organization = Well-Written Essay. The structure of an essay can really make it or break it for you. Make sure that you have strong opening and ceo asda closing paragraphs and vs japan body content that supports your original thesis. The introduction should funnel down to your thesis and narrow down the specific argument you want to make. Body paragraphs must have strong topic sentences and reference credible sources appropriately using the right citation style.

Finally, conclusions should not introduce new information and must recap the main essay points that you presented previously. Adherence to ceo asda, Citation Style Guidelines. Finally, make sure to illegal, properly style your prepared essay in ceo asda, the appropriate citation style. For example, APA style has strict guidelines for cover pages and running heads while Chicago and Turabian require either footnotes or endnotes. Knowing how to cite properly and format things accordingly can be worth upwards of twenty percent of islam? your entire grade. Following the formatting rules is an easy win, but you have to take the time to do it right. Also, always remember to credit another authorís work and donít call it your own, especially if you bought an ceo asda, essay online. While writing good essays is time consuming and tedious, it all comes down to following best practices and being diligent. Our writers follow a clear methodology that is both practical and efficient for getting the best possible outcome. First, make sure to in what way does differ islam?, select a good topic that you can write easily about and make sure you can find scholarly materials about it. Next, take some time to plan and make an outline based around a clear thesis statement.

Proceed to ceo asda, write the body while adhering to strict rules for paragraphs and inclusion of references. Finally, complete your references page and review the draft before submission using quality audit tools. Here, we recommend the same tools that we use if you were to purchase an essay model from euthanasia illegal, us. Essay Topic Selection and Research. Strong topic selection is an important first step. Ceo Asda! If possible, pick a topic that has lots of available research materials or aligns with items you are studying in other classes. Try to avoid current events as there may be a lack of available research materials. Sample Essay Topics. Death penalty Abortion rights Gun rights Gender inequality.

When doing academic research, only theory psychology trust reputable sources like JSTOR, Google Scholar, your campus library or academic search engines you have access to. Ceo Asda! Lastly, collect the sources that you need first and american vs japan go through them thoroughly. Now that you have picked a topic and ceo asda collected some credible sources, itís time to make a plan. Start by identifying common assumptions about the humanistic, topic and ceo asda find common themes. For example, if exploring the causes of way does judaism differ from islam? poverty, you will inevitably find out that governments are the ones that control lots of food production and allocation to the people. Once you have enough evidence to support a general theme, construct a thesis statement and make an outline of the core items that support that assertion. If you don't think this step is necessary, just remember that our writers are trained to ceo asda, follow this process on all purchased sample essay orders. You are ready to start writing. Start with an introductory paragraph that funnels down from in what differ, a broad issue to a specific time and ceo asda place. Provide background details as necessary. Psychology! Then, conclude the ceo asda, introduction with your thesis statement.

Body paragraphs should be 5-7 sentences long and way does differ from start with a topic sentence. Always introduce your quotes and avoid ďdropping themĒ without context. Finish with a conclusion that recaps each main point and make sure not to introduce any new information. Essay References and Final Review. Finally, construct your works cited page using the right citation style guide.

Depending on the format, you may also need a title page. Ceo Asda! Review your final essay by reading it out loud and make sure you addressed your original instructions! You should use EasyBib to quickly build citations in almost any format. Have a friend, teacher or trusted essay editing service review your final draft to make sure it is done properly (if you didn't already buy an essay). References and Considerations Before Buying an Essay. While the previous section described summarized steps towards writing an and controlling overlap all of management process, essay, consider going through our extended 14-Step Essay Writing Guide for a more thorough look at each section. It also includes template that you can download as well as color-coded visual aids. You can also learn about and see examples of essay related terms in our extensive glossary section. Whether you choose to use Ultius for buying essays online or not, we hope that our extensive walkthroughs have helped you in your journey to finding essay help.

Not what you're looking for ceo asda or not convinced? The links below may help. Search hundreds of services. Click to vicks company, Verify. Ultius is proud to have strong verified reviews from ceo asda, different review vendors. Last updated on 16 January 2017 . With every order, you can count on euthanasia the following: Delivered on time 100% original Free revisions Awesome 24/7 support World-class writers. Every order comes with these free features: 275 Words Per Page Free Title Page Free Bibliography Free Revisions American Writers Plagiarism Scan.

Connect with a professional writer by ceo asda, placing your first order. The entire order process takes roughly five minutes and we usually match you with a writer within a few hours. Enter code newcust during checkout and save money on your first order. Have more questions? Get in touch with us or explore common questions. Ultius provides an online platform where we connect you with a freelance writer for sample writing, editing and business writing services. The company encourages and theory psychology expects fair use of our services.

Here are the guidelines. Order Revisions i. The company offers free revisions, but there are some limitations like the deadline and whether we met the ceo asda, original instructions. Sample Writing ii. Custom sample services are for model and humanistic psychology reference use only. When referencing our work, you must use a proper citation. i Revisions are offered within seven (7) days of a completed order and are free with a three-day deadline. For earlier deadlines and ceo asda general changes to core instructions, costs may apply. Explore the full Revision Policy.

ii The company does not condone plagiarism, copyright infringement or any form of illegal academic dishonesty. All provided sample services must only be used for reference purposes while being cited properly. Please read the Fair Use Policy. Ultius is the trusted provider of content solutions for ceo asda consumers around the world. Connect with great American writers and get 24/7 support. Ultius is accredited with the way does judaism from islam?, Better Business Bureau and ceo asda has an A+ rating.

© 2017 Ultius, Inc. Before we chat, please tell us a bit about yourself.